Collars

Best Dog Training Collars: Educator vs Dogtra vs SportDog vs PetSafe vs Pet Resolve vs PetSpy vs SpotOn vs Halo & More

50

Last Updated: March 11, 2024 | 12 min read | 15 Comments

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Here’s how it works.

Do your dogs stop obeying you when they’re off-leash outdoors? Want to take them hiking or when exploring a remote wilderness but frightened they’ll run too far astray? Or do you want a remote collar to help curb negative behaviors such as excessive barking, jumping, food aggression, etc.?

Avid hikers, explorers, and hunters alike swear by remote dog training collars. These wireless collars allow you to train your dogs to obey you when they’re off-leash, giving your pup room to roam — and you peace of mind that your dogs are safely exploring their world.

How do remote collars work? And what are some of the best collar choices for your active family’s canine companion? The best dog training collar is SportDOG 425X, followed by PetSpy M686 for the best mid-range priced collar. If you’re looking for an entry-level option, the best budget-friendly dog collar is the PatPet356A. And you might consider an alternative to collars, like the best virtual fencing for dogs with SpotOn GPS Fence. Let’s dig into more about these top picks and why we chose them. 

At A Glance: Best Dog Training Collars

High-EndMid-RangeBudget-FriendlyVirtual Fencing
SportDOG FieldTrainer 425XPetSpy M686 PremiumPatPet 356A Dog Training Collarspoton collar
SportDOG 425XPetSpy M686PatPet P320SpotOn GPS Fence
View on ChewyVisit Website
Read ReviewRead Review

How Do Remote Dog Training Collars Work?

All remote dog training collars sometimes referred to as e-collars, remote shock collars, or simply remote collars, include the same components: a handheld transmitter, a collar receiver, and collar probes.

You set your transmitter to the type (tone, vibration, or static stimulation) and intensity of stimuli, and the transmitter then sends a radio signal to your dog’s receiver.

The receiver delivers the stimuli you’ve chosen via a set of two stainless steel collar probes that rest on your dog’s neck. The probes must fit against your dog’s skin rather than her fur, so a snug-fitting collar receiver is of utmost importance.

We’ve also included the top dog boundary training collar systems in our reviews here that work in a different way than traditional remote training collars. These systems involve a smart collar, GPS technology, cellular service, and a smartphone app rather than a transmitter.

Best Dog Training Collars

Below are our picks for the best e-collars. We based our rankings on the range, collar fit, performance, pricing, and other factors.

Best High-End: SportDOG FieldTrainer 425X Review

SportDOG FieldTrainer 425X

View on Amazon | View on Chewy | View on Walmart

SportDOG is a well-respected manufacturer of high-quality dog training collars, and the FieldTrainer 425X is a high-performer with a ton of excellent features. Although it’s a bit on the pricey side, it’s extremely durable compared to many budget picks.

It has three easy-to-set training modes: tone, vibration, and 21 levels of both momentary and continuous static stimulation. The collar is made with DryTek technology, making it waterproof and submersible up to 25 feet.

ProsCons
Good 500-yard rangeNeck size is only up to 22 inches
21 adjustable static stimulation levels, as well as tone and vibration settingsNot recommended for dogs under 8 pounds
Rechargeable batteries last 50-70 hours between charges
Remote can accommodate up to 3 dogs (must purchase extra collars)
Waterproof
1-year warranty

Price

Best Mid-Range: PetSpy M686 Premium Training Collar Review

PetSpy M686 Premium

View on Amazon | View on Chewy | View on Walmart

The PetSpy M686 Premium Training Collar is an excellent value and has a much longer range at 1,100 yards than the SportDog. It offers four training modes: vibration, sound, and continuous and intermittent shock. It also has eight adjustable levels of vibration and shock so that you can fine-tune the correction level.

The adjustable collar fits most dogs (10-140 pounds), and the collar receiver is waterproof. The remote has a handy strap and belt clip for easy portability. We also like that this collar’s contact points are made of conductive rubber to prevent skin irritation.

ProsCons
Excellent 1,100-yard rangeNot recommended for dogs under 10 pounds
4 training modes: vibration, sound, and continuous and intermittent shockOnly has 8 stimulation levels
Rechargeable batteries last up to 72 hoursOnly expandable up to 2 dogs
Waterproof
Light on collar for nighttime training
1-year warranty

Price

Best Budget-Friendly: PatPet 320 Dog Training Collar Review

PatPet 356A Dog Training Collar

View PatPet on Amazon | View on Chewy | View on Walmart

The PatPet 320 is the best dog training collar we’ve seen at this price point. It’s durable, reliable, and has good features for a relatively low cost. Although the range is modest at roughly 330 yards, it’s long enough for you to control the collar if you’re in the house and your pup is in the yard. It has three training modes: beep, vibration (1-8 levels), and static shock (1-16 levels).

The adjustable waterproof collar fits neck sizes from 7.8 inches to 27 inches (around 15 to 100 pounds). It also has conductive silicone prongs and metal spring sheets to protect your dog’s skin when using the static mode.

ProsCons
16 adjustable static stimulation levels, as well as beep and vibration settingsSignal range capped at 330 yards
Conductive silicone prong jackets to protect your dog’s skinNot suitable for dogs under 15 pounds or very large dogs
Rechargeable batteriesOnly expandable up to 2 dogs
WaterproofSome complaints about the battery life
Comes in 5 colors
1-year warranty

Price

Best For Virtual Fencing: SpotOn GPS Fence

SpotOn tracker and phone

Visit Website

SpotOn GPS Fence is an easy-to-use, high-tech system that keeps your pup in your yard or within specific boundaries when you’re camping, visiting family, etc. It’s all contained in one collar and a smartphone app without the need for wiring or a transmitter. The best part? After training your dog to understand the system, the collar does all the work for you. And you can even track your pup’s location if he escapes your yard.

How does it work? This system uses data from 25-30 satellites from GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, and Beidou to keep your pup within the boundaries you create virtually. You start by setting up virtual fences (up to 1,500) by walking your property or via a map in the app. Then you customize SpotOn’s collar to keep your dog in-bounds via automatic sound, vibrations, or static correction. It includes excellent training materials, and you also get one-on-one training sessions with one of SpotOn’s certified dog trainers.

The fences work without a monthly subscription, but you must have SpotOn’s AT&T or Verizon cellular coverage service to get alerts that your pup has left the boundary and to be able to track in real-time your dog’s whereabouts on your smartphone.

Our Personal Experience With SpotOn GPS Fence

“We had the opportunity to try SpotOn’s collar with our Cavalier King Charles Spaniel in exchange for an honest review. The collar itself was easy to set up, attach the contact points, and adjust the size. After activating the collar and creating an account, you can walk with your dog on a leash to create your virtual fence in real-time. I was impressed at how detailed and accurate the invisible fence lines were.

When getting close to the “edge,” it makes a loud beep. As you get closer to the boundary, there is a two-tone alert. And if you cross the boundary, the collar vibrates. There’s no subscription required for the fence feedback, but if you want GSP tracking that is an additional monthly fee. If you’re looking for a way to contain your dog without a need for wires, this training collar is worth the investment.”

Sadie Cornelius, Cavalier King Charles Spaniel dog parent
ProsCons
Can create multiple, overlapping wireless fences over 1,000s of acresExpensive
Easy to set upRequires a minimum of 1/2 acre
30 static stimulation levels, as well as tone and vibration settings (use of static shock is optional)Likely won’t fit very small or very large dogs (10″-26″ neck sizes)
Real-time alerts and accurate GPS trackingMust pay a monthly fee for tracking feature to work
IP-67 waterproof rating
Battery life is 14-22 hours depending on the mode you’re using
Mobile apps get good reviews
1-year limited warranty
90-day money-back guarantee
10% discount on multi-collar purchases

Price

SpotOn offers a 90-day money-back guarantee and a one-year warranty.

Monthly Subscription

The optional subscription gives you access to SpotOn’s GPS tracking feature. A one- or two-year plan comes with a 90-day free trial.

  • Month to Month: $9.95/month
  • 1-Year: $7.95/month (save 20%)
  • 2-Years: $5.95/month (save 40%)

Coupon

Use coupon code CANINE to get $50 off your SpotOn purchase via this link.

Full SpotOn GPS Fence Review

What About Dogtra, Educator, Halo & More Popular Collars?

Although the following training collars didn’t make our top picks, each stands out for certain needs you may have.

Bousnic Dog Training Collar Review

Bousnic Dog Training Collar

View on Amazon

The Bousnic training collar is a fantastic value for the features — and you get two receivers, making it a top-budget pick if you have two dogs. Its most noteworthy features include a strong signal, 3 training modes with multiple levels for each, included short and long prongs, and a waterproof, reflective collar for water and nighttime use.

And if you have a little doggy, this collar can accommodate pups as small as five pounds. Users say this system is reliable, incredibly easy to use while training two dogs, has a terrific battery life, and has very durable collars.

ProsCons
Excellent 1,100-yard rangeNot good for dogs over 120 pounds
Multiple levels of tone (1-8), vibration (1-16), and static (1-99) settingsTransmitter only accommodates 2 dogs
Fits dogs 5 pounds and up
Security lock prevents accidental shocks
Prongs have conductive silicone covers
Waterproof collar
1-year warranty

Price

Dogtra IQ-Plus Remote Trainer Review

Dogtra IQ-Plus Remote Trainer

View on Chewy

Dogtra’s collar is plastic and easily adjustable to fit many dog sizes, although the neck size won’t accommodate huge dogs. Dogtra’s collar has a good signal range and adjustable levels of low-to-medium stimulation output. It’s also easy to adjust the levels with one hand by using the front-facing Rheostat Dial.

The good? Dogtra gives you two-hour rapid-charge rechargeable batteries, and the collar is waterproof. The downside? Dogtra’s remote only accommodates two dogs and doesn’t have a tone setting.

ProsCons
Good 400-yard rangeDoesn’t adequately fit dogs under 10 pounds
Stimulation levels from 0-100Not ideal for huge dogs (fits up to 24″ neck)
Vibration settingNo tone setting
2-hour rapid-charge batteriesOnly expandable up to 2 dogs
Waterproof
1-year warranty

Price

Educator E-Collar Review

Educator E-Collar

View on Chewy

The Educator E-Collar Dog Trainer is an excellent alternative to our top picks if you need a longer range than 1,100 yards. The Boss Educator has reliable signal strength up to one mile, making it a solid choice if you are shock collar training a hunting dog or live on a large farm. The receiver delivers a tapping sensation (similar to vibration, but more intense), a tone, and static stimulation.

The Educator comes loaded with many of the fantastic features you’ll find in our top picks. You can even activate a tracking light on your dog’s collar receiver to locate your dog after dark. And it includes two sets of contact points (5/8″ short hair and 3/4″ long hair). The Educator also comes in 3/4 and 1/2-mile ranges.

The Micro Educator is excellent for dogs who weigh as little as five pounds. The range is up to 1/3 mile, is 20% lighter, and has 20% less stimulation than the Educator. The contact points are closer to one another to accommodate breeds with smaller neck sizes.

ProsCons
Up to 1-mile range with excellent signal reliabilityThe Boss (1-mile range) isn’t suitable for dogs under 20 pounds
Adjustable static stimulation levels 1-100 and boost stimulation 1-60More expensive than our top picks (but competitive for one-mile-range dog training collars)
All but The Boss work for dogs as small as 5 poundsOnly expandable up to 2 dogs
Rechargeable batteries
Waterproof
2-year warranty
Excellent customer reviews

Price

Halo Collar 3 Review

Halo 3 Collars

Visit Website

The Halo Collar 3 is another all-in-one smart wireless dog fencing system, GPS activity tracker, and remote training collar that works in the same way as SpotOn GPS Fence. What are the main differences between these two systems? Halo is nearly half the cost of SpotOn, doesn’t require as large of a yard, and comes with dog expert Cesar Millan’s 21-day training program to teach your dog how to adapt to the system.

While SpotOn lets you create up to 1,500 overlapping virtual fences, Halo Collar maxes out at 20 fences that can’t overlap. And Halo has 15 customizable correction levels compared to SpotOn’s 30.

In terms of performance, SpotOn also has arguably more accurate GPS tracking and reliable fencing boundaries than Halo, based on customer reviews we continue to see. However, at nearly half the price, Halo could be a better option for you than SpotOn.

Our Personal Experience With Halo Collar 3

Halo Collar 3 box and contents

“The app walked me through a series of training videos which are super entertaining and informative. The quality is very cinematic, and the text helps reinforce the audio instructions. After learning about types of feedback (prevention and encouragement), I worked on beacon training. This gets your dog accustomed to feedback in a safe, indoor setting. You’ll manually give your dog feedback (sound or stimulation) and a reward to guide them away from the “no-go zone.” You’ll repeat these steps several times for 30 minutes and do at least 3-4 sessions before building up to outdoor boundaries. Eventually, when you turn the beacons on, the beacon will automatically give feedback when your pup gets within a certain range of the no-go zone. Georgie responded well to the feedback and am pleased with the GPS location tracking improvement from the Halo 2+ which we tested previously.”

– Sadie Cornelius, Cavalier King Charles Spaniel dog parent
ProsCons
Ability to easily set up 20 customizable virtual wireless fencesExpensive
15 static stimulation levels, as well as tone and vibration settings (use of static shock is optional)Requires monthly subscription
Uses GPS/GNSS, Bluetooth, WiFi, and LTE technologiesNot for very small dogs (minimum neck size is 11″ and minimum weight is 20 lbs)
IP-67 water-resistant rating
Battery life averages 24 hours
Covers up to 10 square miles
Apps get generally good reviews
1-year limited warranty
30-day return policy
Customer service and tech support via live Zoom sessions, phone, and email

Price

Monthly Subscription

required monthly subscription gets you access to the GPS tracker, training tools, and activity monitoring. Each plan gives you different features and advanced tracking, feedback, and support.

  • Bronze: $5.99/month
  • Silver (recommended): $9.99/month (+ custom support, custom ranges, advanced tracing, instant feedback)
  • Gold: $29.99/month (+ premium training lessons each month, live sessions with trainers)

Coupon Code

Get $25 off using this link and enter the code Halo25.

Full Review Of Halo 2+ Collar

Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar Review

Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar

View on Amazon

The Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar is a great option if you need a long-range system. Its range is up to 3/4 of a mile, and the remote can accommodate up to three dogs. It has three training modes: tone (beep), vibration, and 10 levels of static stimulation. It also has a light for night mode and an anti-bark feature. You can even remove the prongs if you don’t want to use the static stimulation. The battery only takes two hours to recharge. This collar is an excellent value for the range it provides.

ProsCons
Range is 3/4 of a mile (1,312 yards)Only has 10 stimulation levels
2-hour rapid charge batteriesNot suitable for small dogs (good for dogs 15+ pounds)
Remote can accommodate up to 3 dogs (must purchase extra collars)
Removable shock prongs
Waterproof
1-year warranty

Price

PetSafe Remote Trainer Review

PetSafe Remote Trainer

View on Chewy

PetSafe is a leading manufacturer of all types of pet equipment, and their Remote Training Collar is a solid choice. It has 3 training modes: tone (beep), vibration, and 15 levels of static stimulation. The battery life is 40 hours, and it only takes 2 hours to recharge. They even offer a Lite version with less intense stimulation for smaller and more timid dogs.

ProsCons
Available in several ranges: 100, 300, 600, or 900 yardsCollar neck size is limited for giant dogs (up to 23″)
2-hour rapid charge batteriesOnly expandable up to 2 dogs
Fits dogs 8 pounds and upSome complaints that it doesn’t hold a charge
Waterproof
1-year warranty

Price

Petrainer Dog Training Collar Review

Petrainer Dog Training Collar

View on Amazon

Dog training on a tight budget? There are dozens of budget-friendly dog training collars on the market for under $100. You’re not going to get the best dog shock collar at this price range, but many are still effective for basic training purposes. The Petrainer PET998DRB1 model is one of our favorite budget dog training collars for its affordability and features.

Your range is limited compared to many other dog training collars we review here, but you have tone, vibration, and static stimulation modes with plenty of adjustable levels. While the Petrainer is “water-resistant,” it’s not waterproof, so training your dog in water isn’t possible with this collar. Still, Petrainer has plenty of satisfied customers.

ProsCons
Budget-friendlySignal range capped at 330 yards
Beep, vibrate and static stimulation levels 1-100Not recommended for dogs under 15 pounds
Contact points have soft silicone coversCollar neck size is limited for giant dogs (up to 25″)
Rechargeable batteriesSeveral consumer complaints about collar no longer recharging after a few months of use
1-year warranty

Price

Are Shock Collars Harmful To Your Dog?

hound wearing a shock collar sitting outside

The idea of shock collar training turns many owners away, but today’s shock collars are designed to deliver low to medium intensity — and you get to choose the level of intensity. Static stimulation can range anywhere from a mild tingling sensation to an unpleasant shock (similar to the shock you feel with static in your bedsheets, for example), but the shock itself isn’t harmful to your pup.

The Humane Society, however, says that shock collars have the potential to irritate or inflame your dog’s neck. They also point out that misuse of shock collars can create fear, anxiety, and aggression in your dog. If you’re wondering whether you should use the shock feature with these collars, check out our in-depth article on shock collars to see the pros and cons.

Pro Tip: We suggest NOT using these collars until your dog understands basic commands like sit and stay. That way, you know that your dog is able to understand what you’re asking her to do and can associate the correction with the negative behavior.

Tips To Avoid Potential Shock Collar Irritation

Experts recommend taking the following precautions when using a shock collar.

  1. Read your product’s instructions carefully before use to ensure the proper fit.
  2. Don’t leave the electronic collar on for an extended length of time.
  3. Reposition the collar on your dog’s neck every 1 to 2 hours.
  4. Clean the contact points that touch your dog’s neck regularly.

How Do You Transition From Leash Training To An E-Collar?

Check out the video below by SportDOG for an overview of remote collar training vs leash training.

Get Multiple Pet Insurance Quotes Instantly

Are Remote Dog Training Collars Effective?

Yes. Remote training collars are effective in teaching your dog to obey you when she’s off-leash in your yard or within longer distances. But if you’re not sure this type of collar is best for you and your pup, see our recommendations and tips for on-leash dog training collars. We also have guides on other commonly used methods, such as whistle and clicker training.

The information provided through this website should not be used to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease; it is not intended to offer any legal opinion or advice or a substitute for professional safety advice or professional care. Please consult your health care provider, attorney, or product manual for professional advice. Products and services reviewed are provided by third parties; we are not responsible in any way for them, nor do we guarantee their functionality, utility, safety, or reliability. Our content is for educational purposes only.

Subscribe
Notify of
15 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Scroll to Top