Best Dog Subscription Box For Heavy Chewers: Barkbox Super Chewer vs Bullymake

To sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Our review process.

1st
Bullymake logo
2nd
Super Chewer logo
Compare All Products

You get some new “tough” dog toys, and your dog absolutely loves them. But within minutes, stuffing is everywhere, squeakers are extracted from the toys and your dog has destroyed $20 worth of new toys. We all know this situation far too well.

Maybe you perform reconstructive “surgery” on the toy by duct taping it, but that only lasts a short period before your dog tears it to shreds all over again. So much for “tough.”

Quit wasting your money on toys that barely last 5 minutes and start buying dog toys designed for heavy chewers.

Article Overview

Best Box For Heavy Chewers

We chose our winners based on price, number of products and customization options.

Bullymake Review

Barley chewing on toy from Bullymake box

#1

Visit Website

Once you place your Bullymake order, they ship a themed box the next business day. After that, you’ll receive a box every 30 days. You can choose between toys and treats or a toy-only box.

You can also reach out to customer service to change the frequency of deliveries. So instead of receiving a box monthly, you could ask to receive one every other month, once a quarter, etc. You are also able to change the date you receive the boxes.

For example, Michelle, the co-founder of Canine Journal, signed up and received her first box for Barley at the end of November. But sadly, it was Thanksgiving-themed, and turkey day was over. While Barley didn’t discriminate against the turkey leg chew toy, Michelle was a little sad that he didn’t have Christmas-themed toys to enjoy. So she emailed customer service, and they promptly changed the date for future boxes to ship on the first of the month instead. Now they have more time to enjoy the new month’s theme.

When we adopted Barley, we quickly discovered that he LOVES to chew! We tried store-bought toys, but he destroyed every one. In our search for a long-term solution, we researched Super Chewer and Bullymake boxes.

We tried both out, but we chose Bullymake because they offer a toy-only box at the same price. We can buy treats anywhere, but toys are our primary issue (and a rapidly growing expense!). Four new Bullymake toys each month is the perfect solution for Barley.  – Michelle S., Co-Founder of Canine Journal

Bullymake has four types of toys: nylon, rubber, rope and ballistic. Depending on your dog’s toy and play preference, there may be one or two styles that are a better fit. Learn more about the types of toys in the short video below.

We think Bullymake offers the best dog subscription box for heavy chewers because it has a toy-only option, competitive prices, you can choose the toy materials your dog likes best and you can change the delivery frequency.

Pros

Cons

  • Free shipping within the USA
  • Caters to beef, chicken and grain allergies
  • Will replace toys destroyed within 14 days
  • Toys and treats made in the USA
  • Easy-to-navigate website with good FAQs, blog and customer service features
  • Can customize box frequency (contact customercare@bullymake.com)
  • Some toys have holiday or theme-oriented scents (e.g., black bat smelled like licorice)
  • Toy-only option available
  • Subscriptions automatically renew, making canceling necessary
  • No multi-pet discount

Price

Each box includes: 2-3 toys and 3-4 treats or chews. Toy-only box contains 4 toys and no treats.

  • $39/box for 1 month
  • $36/box if you pre-pay for 3 months
  • $34/box if you pre-pay for 6 months
  • $31/box if you pre-pay for 12 months
  • Add an additional toy to your box for $9/month
  • View all options

Barkbox Super Chewer Review

Dog with SuperChewer BarkBox

#2

Visit Website

Each Super Chewer box from Barkbox includes more than $45 worth of toys and treats. The first box ships immediately and all following boxes ship on the 15th of every month.

Boxes have fun themes like The Knights of the Hound Table, Paradise Unleashes and Age of the Furaoh. And if a toy isn’t tough enough for your super chewer, Barkbox will replace it for free, no questions asked.

My power chewing dog especially loved the bouncy rubber carrot that arrived for Thanksgiving! It smelled like almonds, and while he quickly chewed off the “stems,” he still loves chasing the bouncing carrot all over the house, even months later. – Michelle S., Co-Founder of Canine Journal

Customer service is quick to help via text, live chat and email. And if your dog isn’t a super chewer, Barkbox also has a regular box options, which you can learn more about in our Barkbox review.

Even though Barkbox isn’t our #1 pick, we still think it’s a great option, and it’s even a couple dollars cheaper than Bullymake when you sign up for the 12-month subscription. We like their 100% satisfaction guarantee and that they cater to allergies.

The only reason we didn’t select Barkbox’s Super Chewer as #1 is that you can’t choose the toy materials or change the frequency of boxes delivered. Also, you will have to directly request a toy-only option — they don’t offer it during sign up. If these aren’t deal breakers for you, we think the Super Chewer box could be a great pick for your pup.

Pros

Cons

  • Free shipping inside the contiguous 48 United States
  • 100% satisfaction guaranteed
  • Allergy-friendly boxes can exclude beef, chicken and turkey
  • No wheat, corn or soy
  • Easy-to-navigate website with good FAQ, blog and customer service features
  • 6 full-sized products in every box
  • Many toys have holiday or theme-oriented scents (e.g., toy turkey leg smelled like chicken)
  • Toy-only option available, must contact customer service
  • Subscriptions automatically renew, making canceling necessary
  • No multi-pet discount

Price

Each box includes: 2 tough and fluff-free toys, 2 full-sized bags of treats made in the USA or Canada and 2 all-natural meaty chews. You can reach out to Barkbox’s customer service for a toy-only option, but we’re unsure if the price changes for those boxes.

  • $39 for 1 box (month-to-month plan)
  • $34 per box for 6-month subscription
  • $29 per box for 12-month subscription
  • Extra Toy Club — get an additional toy in every box for $9/month

Coupon

  • BarkBox: Our readers can order their first box for only $10. Click here to take advantage of this offer.
  • Super Chewer: Subscribe to Super Chewer today and receive $9 off your first box. Click here to take advantage of this offer.
Offers are subject to change.

Read Our Full Review Of Barkbox Super Chewer

Comparison Table

This comparison table may help you see the key differences between these two companies more easily.

 Barkbox Super ChewerBullymake
1 Month Subscription$39$39
3 Month SubscriptionN/A$36
6 Month Subscription$34$34
12 Month Subscription$29$31
Add Extra Toy$9$9
Each Box Includes2 Toys, 2 Bags Of Treats, 2 Meaty Chews2-3 Toys & 3-4 Treats/Chews
(4 Toys In Toy Only Box)
Toy Only BoxContact Customer ServiceCheckmark
Free ShippingContiguous 48 United StatesWithin The United States
Satisfaction GuaranteeAny TimeWithin 14 Days
Choose Toy MaterialCheckmark
Caters To AllergiesCheckmarkCheckmark
Change Delivery FrequencyCheckmark
Themed BoxesCheckmarkCheckmark

Best Indestructible Dog Toys

If you’d rather skip the subscription boxes and purchase toys individually for your heavy chewer, consider these indestructible dog toys. These toys have some of the best reviews from pet parents with super chewers.

What toy seems to last the longest for your dog?

About The Author:

Kimberly received her Bachelor of Arts in multimedia journalism from Simpson College. She has been writing about dogs since 2014, covering subjects such as dog insurance, training, health, accessories and more. Her natural curiosity helps her research as she seeks the truth when learning about, comparing and personally testing canine products and services. With every piece she writes, her goal is to help our readers find the best fit for their unique needs.

Kimberly grew up in a family that loved Labrador Retrievers and remembers running and playing in the yard with them as a child. In 2017, she and her husband adopted their Coonhound mix, Sally, from a local shelter. Kimberly's research was put to good use since Sally faced some aggression issues with other dogs and needed some training to be an inside dog. She worked daily with Sally and sought help from professionals to help Sally become the happy pup she is today.

One of Kimberly's favorite pastimes is spoiling Sally with new toys, comfy beds and yummy treats (she even makes homemade goodies for her). She tries to purchase the safest products for Sally and knows that each canine has their own specific likes and dislikes. Kimberly is passionate about dogs, and knows the bond between humans and canines is like no other.

Disclaimer: This website contains reviews, opinions and information regarding products and services manufactured or provided by third parties. We are not responsible in any way for such products and services, and nothing contained here should be construed as a guarantee of the functionality, utility, safety or reliability of any product or services reviewed or discussed. Please follow the directions provided by the manufacturer or service provider when using any product or service reviewed or discussed on this website.

Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
Newest
Oldest Most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Valentina m liao#.19259980440kit
March 12, 2020 2:12 pm

I love that bark box products for my pet dogs to use and chew on,and treats to eat for them too. Love them.kit with your jobs for pets products and stuff like that.i order it every 6months to my home.