Icon Toys (Outline) Toys

Best Dog Subscription Box For Heavy Chewers: BarkBox Super Chewer vs Bullymake vs BoxDog

50

Last Updated: April 30, 2024 | 5 min read | 3 Comments

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Here’s how it works.

Best OverallBest ValueBest Customizable
Bullymake BoxBarkboxDog sniffing BoxDog toys in the box.
Bullymake logoBark Super Chewer LogoBoxDog logo 125
Visit WebsiteVisit WebsiteVisit Website
Read ReviewRead ReviewRead Review

You get some new tough dog toys, and your dog loves them. But within minutes, stuffing is everywhere, the squeakers extracted, and your dog has destroyed $20 worth of new toys. I know this situation far too well.

You could perform reconstructive surgery on the toy by duct-taping it, but that only lasts a short period before your dog tears it all over again. So much for this toy being “tough.” I was tired of wasting my money on toys that barely lasted five minutes and started getting dog toys designed for heavy chewers delivered to our doorstep regularly.

Best Dog Toy Subscription For Heavy Chewers

I chose the dog toy subscription box for heavy chewers winners based on price, number of products, personal experience, and customization options.

Best Overall: Bullymake Review

Bullymake Box.

Visit Website

Bullymake offers the best dog subscription box for heavy chewers. They have a toy-only option and competitive prices. You can choose the toy materials your dog likes best and change the delivery frequency.

Once you place your Bullymake order, they ship a themed box the next business day. After that, you’ll receive a package every 30 days. You can choose between durable toys and treats or a toy-only box.

You can also contact customer service to change the frequency of deliveries. Instead of receiving a box monthly, you could ask to receive one every other month, once a quarter, etc. You can also change the date you receive the boxes.

Barley dog tugging on bully make toy next to box.
Barley is enjoying one of his new rope toys from Bullymake.

For example, I signed up and received my first box for Barley at the end of November. But sadly, it was Thanksgiving-themed, and turkey day was over. While Barley didn’t discriminate against the turkey leg chew toy, I was a little sad that he didn’t have Christmas-themed toys to enjoy.

So I emailed customer service, and they promptly changed the date for future boxes to ship on the first of the month instead. Now we have more time to enjoy the new month’s theme.

I love Bullymake because they offer a toy-only box. We can buy treats anywhere, but toys are our primary issue (and a rapidly growing expense!). Four new Bullymake toys each month is the perfect solution for Barley. 

Bullymake offers four types of toys: nylon, rubber, rope, and ballistic. Depending on your dog’s toy and play preferences, one or two styles may be a better fit. See some of the toys and treats you can expect to receive from Bullymake in the short video below.

ProsCons
Free shipping within the USASubscriptions automatically renew, making canceling necessary
Caters to beef, chicken, and grain allergiesNo multi-pet discount
Will replace toys destroyed within 14 days
Toys and treats made in the USA
An easy-to-navigate website with good FAQs, blog, and customer service features
Can customize box frequency
Some toys have holiday or theme-oriented scents (e.g., black bat smells like licorice)
Toy-only option available

Price

Each box includes 2 to 3 super chewer dog toys and 3 treats or chews. The toy-only box contains 4 to 5 toys and no treats.

  • $45/box for 1 month
  • $39/box if you prepay for 3 months
  • $35/box if you prepay for 6 months
  • $31/box if you prepay for 12 months

You can add the following items to your box for $12/month each:

  • Extra toy
  • Dental treats
  • Hip & joint supplement
  • Calming supplement

View all options

Best Value: BarkBox Super Chewer Review

Bark Box.

Visit Website

Each BarkBox Super Chewer box includes a seasonal box of toys and treats. The first box ships immediately, and all following boxes ship on the 15th of every month.

Boxes have fun themes like Barkbuster Movie Night, Spongebob Squarepants, and Give N’ Thanks. So, if your dog is easily bored, this box will continue to surprise them with new things. And if a toy isn’t tough enough for your super chewer, BarkBox will replace it for free, no questions asked.

Dog sniffing bark box contents on the floor.
My power-chewing dog especially loved the bouncy rubber carrot that arrived for Thanksgiving! It smelled like almonds, and while he quickly chewed off the cloth “stems,” he still loves chasing it all over the house, even years later.

Customer service is quick to help via text, live chat, and email. And if your dog isn’t a super chewer, BarkBox also has a standard box option. Although I prefer Bullymake vs Super Chewer, BarkBox is highly reputable and less expensive than Bullymake.

I like their 100% satisfaction guarantee and the fact that they cater to allergies. Plus, every new subscriber gets twice as many treats and toys (4 of each) in their first box.

ProsCons
Free shipping inside the contiguous 48 United StatesSubscriptions automatically renew, making canceling necessary
100% satisfaction guaranteedNo multi-pet discount
Allergy-friendly boxes can exclude beef, chicken, and turkey
No wheat, corn, or soy
An easy-to-navigate website with good FAQ, blog, and customer service features
4 full-sized products in every box
Many toys have holiday or theme-oriented scents (e.g., toy turkey leg smells like poultry)
Toy-only option available must contact customer service
Made in the United States or Canada

Price

Each box includes 2 tough toys and 2 full-sized bags of treats made in the USA or Canada. You can contact Barkbox’s customer service for a toy-only option, but we’re unsure if the price changes for those boxes.

  • $39 per box for month-to-month plan
  • $29 per box for 6-month subscription
  • $24 per box for 12-month subscription

You can add the following items to your box:

  • Extra toy for $9/month
  • Extra toy, beef food topper, and extra treat bag for $19/month
BarkBox Super Chewer Discount

Subscribe to Super Chewer today and receive a free splash pad. No promo code is needed; just use this link and click on “claim offer” to take advantage of these offers.

In-Depth Review Of BarkBox Super Chewer

Read our complete BarkBox Super Chewer review to learn more about this subscription box.

Best Customizable: BoxDog Review

Dog sniffing BoxDog toys in the box.

Visit Website

BoxDog lets you choose the toys and gear for your dog in each box. Boxes can be delivered monthly or quarterly. The quarterly boxes include an extra bag of treats compared to the monthly boxes.

Each box has one specialty item, such as a vegan skincare product like shampoos, balms, and CBD oils or chews, differentiating BoxDog from Bullymake and BarkBox. Treat bags are selected for you, but you get to choose the toys, accessories, and clothing that are in each box because you know what your dog likes best.

Another differentiator for BoxDog is that all treats are handmade and can be eaten by you and your dog. Ingredients are listed on the packaging, and treats use many of the same items used to bake human food.

ProsCons
Free shipping within the United StatesSubscriptions automatically renew, making canceling necessary
Customizations for toys and gearNo multi-pet discount
Deeper discounts on prepaid plansWebsite isn’t as easy to navigate as BarkBox and Bullymake
Handmade treats

Pricing

  • Monthly Box: starting at $35/month
    • 2 bags of handmade treats
    • 1 specialty item (skincare, chew, etc.)
    • 2-3 toys or gear that you choose
  • Seasonal Box: starting at $45/quarter
    • 3 bags of handmade treats
    • 1 specialty item (skincare, chew, etc.)
    • 2-3 toys or gear that you choose
  • View all options

Comparison Table: Bullymake vs BarkBox Super Chewer vs BoxDog

This comparison table may help you see the key differences more easily between the three companies we reviewed.

 BullymakeBarkBox Super ChewerBoxDog
1 Month Subscription$45$39$45
3 Month Subscription$39N/AN/A
6 Month Subscription$35$29$40
12 Month Subscription$31$24$35
Add Extra Toy$12$9N/A
Each Box Includes2-3 Toys & 3 Treats/Chews
(4-5 Toys In Toy Only Box)
2 Toys & 2 Bags Of Treats2-3 Bags Of Treats, 1 Specialty Item (Skincare, Chew, etc.), 2-3 Toys Or Gear
Toy Only BoxCheckmarkContact Customer ServiceN/A
Free ShippingWithin The United StatesContiguous 48 United StatesContiguous 48 United States
Satisfaction GuaranteeWithin 14 DaysAny TimeUnavailable
Choose Toy MaterialCheckmark  
Caters To AllergiesCheckmarkCheckmarkCheckmark
Change Delivery FrequencyCheckmark  
Themed BoxesCheckmarkCheckmark 

Best Indestructible Dog Toys You Can Buy On Their Own

If you’d rather skip the subscription boxes and purchase toys individually for your heavy chewer, consider these indestructible dog toys. These toys have some of the best reviews from pet parents with super chewers.

Why Trust Canine Journal?

Michelle has 20+ years of experience buying dog toys for aggressive chewers of all sizes. She knows what works and, more importantly, what doesn’t work. Michelle has used many of the products in this article with her own dogs. She understands toy materials and how much they can impact the longevity of a toy and health risks as well.

The information provided through this website should not be used to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease; it is not intended to offer any legal opinion or advice or a substitute for professional safety advice or professional care. Please consult your health care provider, attorney, or product manual for professional advice. Products and services reviewed are provided by third parties; we are not responsible in any way for them, nor do we guarantee their functionality, utility, safety, or reliability. Our content is for educational purposes only.

Subscribe
Notify of
3 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Scroll to Top