Best Indestructible Dog Toys For Aggressive Chewers

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Here’s how it works.

Are you tired of spending your hard-earned dollars on dog toys, only to have them become potentially hazardous bits and pieces around your house within minutes? If your dog destroys every toy you buy, we’ve got some solutions for you that can withstand colossal chewers. One of the most frustrating parts of being a dog owner is buying a fun new toy for your dog only to find it destroyed within five minutes. That’s not only hard on your wallet, but it can also be dangerous for your dog. Unfortunately, we’ve all been there.

Here are my top six recommendations for the best dog toys for aggressive chewers by category (along with some tips on dealing with your heavy chewer).

For Fetch	Durable	Teeth Cleaning	Interactive	Dual Action	Tug of War
Orbee-Tuff	Kong	Mammoth Rope	West Paw	Nylabone	Goughnuts
Read Review	Read Review	Read Review	Read Review	Read Review	Read Review
View on Chewy	View on Chewy	View on Amazon	View on Chewy	View on Chewy	View on Chewy

3 Levels: What Type Of Chewer Is My Dog?

The first step in finding the most indestructible and longest-lasting toy is determining what type of chewer your dog is. There are three chewing styles:

1. Gentle Chewers: these dogs prefer fabric and plush dog toys. They usually like to lick or suck on the toys and not chew them up.
2. Average Chewers: these dogs love to play with all different types of toys and like to carry them around with them. They can tear up the fabric toys but rarely deconstruct the rubber ones.
3. Powerful Chewers: These dogs are determined and aggressive chewers. Their pet parents must be selective in picking out the best chew toys for aggressive chewers. Most power chewers prefer large, hard rubber toys. If you have this kind of chewer, keep reading.

Best Indestructible Dog Toys For Aggressive Chewers

Below are some of the best indestructible dog toys I’ve found.

Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Treat Dispensing Planet Ball Review

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

This treat-dispensing toy is soft and flexible, so it’s got the “chew” factor that most dogs love. It also bounces well, so it’s great for tossing and playing fetch. Many reviewers also say it’s easy to extract from your dog’s mouth.

It is highly durable and dispenses treats, keeping your pup mentally engaged. The planet ball is BPA, lead, and phthalate-free. It also has a light mint scent that helps freshen Fido’s breath.

Price

• $12.99

Kong Extreme Review

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

Kong has been around since the 1970s. The Kong Extreme is made of rubber and is very durable for the most powerful chewers. The “Extreme” Kong is thicker and stronger than the “Classic” Kong and was specifically made to stand up to aggressive chewers. Bonus: it’s easy to wash and doesn’t have an odor. And you can fill it with treats, cheese, or peanut butter for added fun.

Price

• Starting at: $8.99

Mammoth Flossy Chews 3-Knot Rope Tug Review

View on Amazon

This is the rope toy of ALL rope toys. This indestructible rope dog toy is two inches thick and is great for heavy chewers. It also cleans their teeth. If you have a dog who likes to play tug of war, this toy is for you. It’s also a good toy for playing fetch.

Price

• Starting at:

West Paw Zogoflex Tux Treat Stuffable Chew Review

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

This dog treat toy is durable and allows your dog to work for the treat. It’s tossable, stuffable, pliable, and recyclable. It’s even dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning.

Price

• $19.95

Nylabone Double Action Chew Review

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

This Nylabone features dental nubs to control tartar and plaque buildup. Different versions are available for your dog’s size. The center of the bone allows for easy carrying, and the durable nylon ends massage the gums during powerful chewing.

Before purchasing, we encourage you to read about Nylabone product warnings.

Price

• Starting at: $16.55

Goughnuts Tug Pull Dog Toy Review

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

This toy is for larger dogs who are power chewers. It’s great for dogs who love to play tug of war. Dogs love chewing and pulling on this durable toy.

Price

• Starting at: $27.68

5 Dog Chew Toy Safety Tips

1. Toys should be appropriate for your dog’s size. Small toys can be easily ingested and lodged in your dog’s throat if the toy is too little for your dog.
2. Consider removing the squeaker in the center of some toys because some dogs find it challenging to locate the source of the squeaking and can choke on this device.
3. Stuffing and fillers, such as polystyrene beads and nutshells, can be dangerous. Avoid chew toys with lots of stuffing; these are not good choices for aggressive chewers.
4. Remove eyes, strings, and ribbons that they can easily swallow.
5. Use caution with chew toys and puppies. Be sure the one you pick is safe and the right size for puppies. Remember, they have smaller teeth but can be quite aggressive due to teething.

Want Tough Chew Toys Delivered Regularly?

If you want to keep your aggressive chewer entertained with new, tough toys regularly, you might consider subscribing to a monthly super chewer box. These companies deliver some of the toughest toys (and treats) right to your door.

If you want more dog toy ideas, check out our article reviewing the best dog toys. This is an excellent place to start since they are highly ranked toys by pet parents, so you can find out what types of toys your dog prefers. We also look at what dogs really think of their toys and interactive toys to keep your pup’s brain engaged.

Frequently Asked Questions

I know there are lots of questions about aggressive chewers and indestructible chew toys for dogs. I’ve covered a few of the most asked below, but if I didn’t get to yours let me know in the comments.

Is There A Dog Toy That Can’t Be Destroyed?

While many dog toys are marketed as indestructible, if you have an aggressive chewer, you know that a determined dog can destroy just about anything. Dog toys made out of rubber are more challenging to tear apart and shred, so they last longer. However, many pups don’t like the taste of rubber and are not interested in those kinds of toys. It’s hard to say if there is any dog toy that is truly 100% indestructible.

What Is The World’s Strongest Dog Toy?

Kong and Nylabone are known for being very strong. As mentioned above, chew toys made from rubber—some even use ballistic rubber—are much harder for dogs to chew through.

Are Antlers Safe For My Aggressive Chewer?

Antlers are not safe for your dog. Though they are quite tough, antlers can damage your pup’s teeth and cause an internal blockage if parts of them are ingested. Most vets advise against giving your pup antlers due to these risks. They are particularly dangerous for aggressive chewers. I suggest a bully stick instead.

Keep Those Canine Teeth Healthy

Your dog’s chompers do a lot of work, and keeping them healthy is essential. Chew toys are great to keep them occupied but are not enough to keep your pup’s teeth healthy. Periodontal disease is one of the most common canine diseases, yet one of the most overlooked care areas. You might be surprised to learn that over 80% of dogs over three years show signs of periodontal disease. Your pup needs regular teeth brushing and occasional professional cleanings at the vet to help keep their teeth in top shape. Discuss dental care with your vet to be sure your pup’s mouth is healthy, and learn more about how much a dog teeth cleaning costs. You may want to consider pet dental insurance as well. We also cover how to clean your dog’s teeth without a toothbrush.

Why Trust Canine Journal?

Kimberly has written about various dog-related topics, such as chew toys, pet insurance, health conditions, treats, training, and more, for over ten years. She consulted with other Canine Journal team members about their favorite indestructible chew toys and spent over six hours researching and writing this article.