Best Pet Sitting Websites 2021: Rover vs Wag vs Care vs Fetch vs PetSitters

4 dogs at feet of owners on leash (caption: Best Pet Sitting Websites)Are you going out of town for vacation? Or maybe you’re working long hours and don’t have time to get home to take out Fido? Some modern-day dog sitting services are like Airbnb for pups, giving them the luxury of a homestay with the freedom and attention they deserve while you’re away. Some even offer other services like grooming, walking, and training. Now isn’t that preferable to a crowded kennel or roughing it in a cage?

There are also more traditional professionals who have certifications and are part of trusted organizations. But how do you find the best pet sitter, and how much do the top pet sitting websites cost? Read on to find the best fit for your needs.

Article Overview

Why Dog Sitting vs Kennel Or Boarding?

As of 2020, there were more than 63.4 million households that own dogs in the United States1. The number has only increased over time, including the pandemic boom of pet adoptions and new pets. That’s a lot of dogs that need love and attention. Combine that with our busy lives, and you may find it challenging to take your dog on walks and feed him throughout the day (or when you’re traveling). That’s where dog-sitting services come to the rescue.

What are the benefits of dog sitting over a traditional kennel or boarding?

  • Flexibility – No restrictions for boarding center options. You work with the sitter to set your drop-off and pick-up times on your schedule.
  • Convenience – Some sitters offer to pick up and drop off your pet. You’re likely to find a sitter in your neighborhood (also good for finding sitters while traveling).
  • Peace Of Mind – Most pet sitting services have limited insurance that will cover some damages or theft, should the sitter be guilty of the act.
  • One-On-One Attention – Nothing beats knowing your beloved animal is in a loving, happy home with someone who will give them extra love and the freedom to roam around.
  • Familiarity & Consistency – If you find a sitter you like, you can build trust with them and have a home away from home (or in your home) for your pup.
  • Personalized Service – In addition to more attention and lots of walks, the sitter will feed your pup, play with them, administer medications, and more.

Why Dog Sitting Is Better Than Boarding

Keep An Eye On Your Pup While Away

Man holding smartphone with security camera footage on screen (caption: Best Security System For Dog Owners)While it’s illegal to use indoor video cameras on guests without their knowledge, a popular use of a home security system is to use the security cameras as pet cams. Aim the cameras at your pup’s crate or where they spend time in your home.

This way, you can keep an eye on them, see what they’re up to, and make sure they’re okay. This can help put your mind at ease and let you enjoy your outing.

What You Must Know Before Reading Our Reviews

Pet sitting rates vary based on location, experience, and type of pet. We also encourage you to do your due diligence before booking a sitter.

Proceed With Caution

While we have personally had great experiences with these services, we are also aware of many disappointments from other customers. Many online pet sitters are untrained, non-professional, unlicensed individuals. A love for pets is what brought them to work in this business, but a lack of knowledge, experience, CPR, and first aid training may lead to complex and heart-wrenching circumstances.

Rover background checkMany companies claim that they run background checks on the contracted sitters you can find on their sites. A background check into the criminal history of any contractor can give you peace of mind that your dog walker may not rob your house or has a criminal history of animal-related offenses. But in no other way can a background check predict how a total stranger will care for your dog.

Treat your dogs as you would your children. Would you trust a childcare provider without getting personal references and word-of-mouth recommendations from your trusted friends and acquaintances? No. For this reason, we strongly urge you to take these same steps for the care of your dogs, no matter what service you use.

Be sure to choose sitters who have a long history of positive reviews. We have read several complaints of sitters hired to come to the house but then don’t visit enough for feedings, walks, potty breaks, etc. Be sure to discuss in detail your expectations and make sure they are taking notes. We also recommend that you always meet the sitter before leaving your pet to make sure you are comfortable with the person, their schedule, the lodging situation, etc.

If you have any concerns about your pet staying with an unlicensed and unbonded individual, use an accredited sitter from one of the organizations listed after the reviews to find someone who better meets your needs.

Best Pet Sitting Websites And Apps

Below are our top picks for the best pet sitting websites that also have apps so you can book, track, and message sitters on the go.

Rover | Wag!

Rover Review

Rover logo

Visit Website

Rover is an online platform that allows pet owners to connect with independently contracted pet sitters to care for your pet at your home, or your pet can stay at the sitter’s house. Browse their site by zip code and view the possible sitters in your local area.

Rover provides reviews of dog sitters and shows their availability dates. Also, sitters receive “badges” for various pet care best practice training sessions. Dog sitting rates are listed upfront, along with the services offered and what types of animals the sitter accepts. Rover offers 24/7 support, a reservation guarantee, and a Rover Guarantee that reimburses you for vet care injuries to a pet in a sitter’s care caused by a Rover sitter, vet care injuries to the sitter’s pets caused by a “Rover Dog,” and physical damages to a pet owner’s personal property caused by the sitter. Reimbursement for vet care is up to $25,000 per incident and for property damage or certain third-party injuries is up to $1,000,000 per incident (both subject to a $250 deductible).

Personally, we have had great experiences both as a sitter and using the service for dog sitting, but we understand that not everyone has. So, as mentioned above, be sure to research the sitter options, read their reviews carefully, and do a meet and greet in the home to make sure you are comfortable with the situation before leaving your dog. Rover merged with DogVacay, another dog sitting website, in 2017.

Coupon Code

Use this link and you will receive a $10 credit towards your first booking with Rover!

Read Our In-Depth Rover Review

Wag! Review

Wag logo

Visit Website

Similar to Rover, Wag is one of our other top picks for the best pet sitting app. They are a popular dog walking app but also offer other services, including sitting and training. Wag requires criminal background checks and provides training for sitters.

Your home is protected up to $1 million when booking a walking or sitting service. They even provide a lockbox to store your key if you opt for sitters to stay in your home. When your dog is with a Wag sitter, you’ll get activity reports and GPS tracking for walks. Wag is currently in more than 4,600 cities nationwide.

Other Dog Sitting Services

In addition to the dog sitting apps we recommend above, here’s a quick overview of some other popular online pet sitting and dog watching services as well as resources to find care for your pet.

Care.com Review

Care.com logo

Visit Website

Care.com offers pet care in addition to other types of care (senior, child, etc.). For pets, they will pet sit, walk your dog, train, groom, and board them as you need. How does it work? Sign up for an account and create the job you need to be completed, e.g., a pet sitter for a weekend.

Care.com guarantees that caregivers will contact you within three days after posting your job. So, given this extra lead time, you will need to plan for your job. Once they respond, you can review the profiles of the candidates and request criminal background checks. You can then conduct interviews and check references to hire whomever you like best.

Fetch! Pet Care Review

Fetch! Pet Care logo (tag line: We've got your tail covered)

Visit Website

Fetch! Pet Care does things differently. You don’t get to hand-pick your sitter. Instead, Fetch! matches every client to the most qualified sitter in your area who’s available on your dates. They also schedule a free in-home consultation for you and the sitter to meet. The website also has clients’ testimonials.

Each sitter goes through a criminal background check, and your dog has limited insurance during the reservation. You should expect to receive updates via text, email, and phone calls to know how your pup is doing. Fetch! also offers dog walking and overnight visits.

HouseCarers Review

HouseCarers.com logo

Visit Website

HouseCarers matches you with a house sitter in your area. The house sitter will take care of your home and pets while you are away, so you don’t have to worry about boarding. Your house will also look “lived in” while you are away so that criminals won’t see your home as a target.

The downside is that HouseCarers does not have any guarantees and does not perform a criminal background check. When we searched for a house sitter near our area, we found results for people who were available for any location — not necessarily locals. We thought this was strange and not very helpful.

National Association Of Professional Pet Sitters (NAPPS) Review

Petsitters.org NAPP logo

Visit Website

Petsitters.org (run by the National Association of Professional Pet Sitters) isn’t a pet sitting service, but it’s a good resource to locate NAPPS-accredited pet sitters in your area. There are no reviews of the sitters, so you can’t see how they have done in the past. You have to do a bit of your own investigative work for this one: contact the person, conduct an interview, ask for references, conduct a background check, etc.

Pet Sitters International (PSI) Review

Pet Sitters International (PSI) logo

Visit Website

Similar to NAPPS, Pet Sitters International (aka PSI) helps you find local pet sitters that are members of their organization. Enter your zip code, and it gives you a listing of professional services in the area along with a description and details. You don’t book through PSI. You go to the company’s website or email them directly. They do indicate if a business is insured, bonded, trained in first aid, certified, has a background check, and more.

Make Sure Your Sitter Is Bonded And Insured

You’ll want to hire a pet sitter that is bonded and insured. What does this mean?

Bonding

Bonding for pet sitters protects the dog sitting company against employee theft. How does this work? If something goes missing while a pet sitter is staying in your home and you accuse the sitter of potential theft (should the police become involved and convict the sitter of the crime), then the bond would be covered by the company. The guilty sitter would then be responsible for paying back the bond to the company.

Insurance

If your provider has pet sitting insurance, your property is protected from any damage that the sitter may cause while in your home. Some policies extend coverage to include items stolen from your home during a house sitter’s stay. So, make sure that your pet sitter has insurance before contracting with them.

Pet Health Insurance

Dog at the vet getting checked out (caption: Pet Insurance Comparison)What happens if your pet gets sick while under someone else’s care? No worries. If your dog doesn’t already have pet health insurance, some pet sitting services offer it for accidents, illnesses, and injuries to your pup (or others) during any pet sitter stay.

For instance, Rover.com comes with a Rover Guarantee, an added layer of protection when the responsible party is unable or unwilling to pay for costs arising from damage or injury attributable to his or her negligence (when insurance is not available).

Best Pet Sitting Infographic

We summarized some of the benefits and why you should try out one of these services in the infographic below.

Source: Best Pet Sitting Websites

How Much To Pay A Dog Sitter

Trusting someone with your beloved pet is a big deal that comes with a huge responsibility. For that reason, it’s priceless. But how much to pay a dog sitter depends on your preferences and circumstances. If you have a higher maintenance dog on medication or one that has special needs, it might be worth it to pay someone who is certified and only keeps one pet at a time.

However, if you have a laid-back dog that loves to sleep, you might feel more comfortable leaving them with a less-trained professional from a site like Wag! or Rover. Pet sitting costs also vary based on location and are typically more expensive in larger cities like New York and San Francisco. However, in rural areas, the average sitter probably runs slightly less due to their lower cost of living and expenses.

Do You Tip Dog Sitter?

It’s typically not expected to tip sitters. With that said, if you feel your sitter went above and beyond and you’d like to tip, surely sitters will welcome it. Rover and Wag! both offer tipping as an option, but it’s usually only used around the holiday season or in special circumstances like last-minute bookings.

Rover and Wag allow sitters to set their own rate so if they feel they are undercharging, they can always increase their fees. Tips can come in other forms of payment like souvenirs from your trip if traveling or a gift they might appreciate.

Is Pet Sitting Better Than Boarding?

The next time you’re leaving town or working late, you may want to search for a dog sitter online. That way, your dog can stay in the comfort of his home and not be boarded at a strange place where he may or may not be comfortable.

Want to take your pet with you on your next trip? Learn some tips for successfully traveling with your pet. Are you interested in becoming a pet sitter? Read our dog sitting guide to get started. And lastly, check out our reviews of dog walking apps if you need some help while you’re at work or running errands.

Have you used a pet sitter before? What was your experience?

Source: [1] APPA


Comment Below

Comments (93)