When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Here’s how it works.
Trying to choose the right food for your dog? Two brands you’ll likely come across are American Journey and Blue Buffalo. One is Chewy’s value-driven house brand known for solid ingredients at a lower price point, while the other is a long-established premium brand offering one of the widest selections of dog food formulas on the market.
Table of Contents
We compare recall history, ingredient quality, and available formulas across life stages so you can decide which option best fits your dog’s needs. Because the right diet plays a key role in digestion, skin and coat health, and long-term wellness, this American Journey vs Blue Buffalo comparison covers everything you need to know before choosing what goes in your dog’s bowl.
| Puppy Top Pick | Adult Top Pick | Senior Top Pick |
|---|---|---|
 |  |  |
| Blue Buffalo | American Journey | Blue Buffalo |
| View on Amazon | View on Chewy | View on Amazon |
| Read Review | Read Review | Read Review |
Brand Histories
Choosing a healthy dog food isn’t just about ingredients on the label. Understanding where a brand comes from and how it approaches formulation can help explain who its recipes are designed for and what priorities guide its decisions.
American Journey
American Journey is Chewy’s in-house dog food brand, introduced in 2017 as a more affordable alternative to premium pet foods. The goal was to offer recipes with real meat as the first ingredient and no corn, wheat, or soy — without the higher price tags typically associated with boutique brands.
Because American Journey is owned and distributed by Chewy, its product line is intentionally streamlined and value-focused. The brand offers grain-free and grain-inclusive formulas, along with limited-ingredient options, but avoids heavy specialization or niche health claims.
American Journey appeals most to dog owners looking for solid ingredient quality at a lower cost, without paying for extensive branding or specialty formulas.
Blue Buffalo
Blue Buffalo was founded in 2003 by the Bishop family in Connecticut after the loss of their dog, Blue, to cancer. From the start, the brand focused on making dog food with real meat and recognizable ingredients, while avoiding artificial flavors, preservatives, and poultry by-products.
Today, Blue Buffalo is one of the most established natural dog food brands in the U.S., offering an expansive lineup that includes:
- grain-free and grain-inclusive recipes
- limited-ingredient and sensitivity-focused formulas
- high-protein, weight management, and specialty diets
Now owned by General Mills, Blue Buffalo emphasizes variety, formulation depth, and targeted nutrition, appealing to owners who want more options tailored to their dog’s life stage, size, or specific needs.
Product Recall History
When the quality or the safety of products doesn’t meet expectations, the pet food company voluntarily recalls, or the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) withdraws the affected products from the market.
Recall history can help you understand a brand’s quality control track record and how it responds when something goes wrong. While recalls aren’t the only measure of safety, they’re still a useful data point when you’re comparing brands side by side.
American Journey
American Journey has no publicly reported dog food recalls to date. Because American Journey is a newer, smaller-line brand (launched in 2017), it’s also worth keeping context in mind: fewer years on the market and fewer products being sold can mean fewer opportunities for recall events compared to long-established national brands.
Blue Buffalo
Blue Buffalo has had several voluntary recalls/market withdrawals since 2003, most occurring between 2007 and 2017. Here’s a verified, high-level recap:
- April 2007 (industry-wide): Blue Buffalo was among many brands affected by the broader melamine contamination crisis tied to contaminated ingredients used across the pet food industry.
- October 2010: Voluntary recall tied to potentially elevated vitamin D levels, which can be dangerous at high levels.
- November 2015: Voluntary recall of one lot of chew bones due to potential Salmonella contamination.
- May 2016: Voluntary recall of a limited amount of dry food due to excess moisture, which can increase mold risk.
- February 2017: Voluntary recall of a limited run of canned food due to possible aluminum metal contamination.
- March 2017: Voluntary market withdrawal of certain cup-style wet foods due to foil seal quality issues (no illnesses reported in that notice).
- March 2017: Voluntary recall of one lot of canned food due to potentially elevated naturally occurring beef thyroid hormones.
Blue Buffalo’s recall history reflects more years on the market and larger production volume, while American Journey’s clean record reflects a shorter history and smaller footprint.
What’s Really In The Bowl? Ingredients Compared
Ingredients matter, but so does how a brand builds its recipes overall (protein sources, carbs, added nutrients, and how consistent the lineup is). Both American Journey and Blue Buffalo position themselves as “real meat first” brands, but they take different approaches to variety, specialty formulations, and add-ins.
What Both Brands Do Well
- Real meat as the first ingredient is common across many formulas for both brands.
- Both offer grain-free and grain-inclusive options, which helps owners match diet style to their dog’s tolerance and preferences.
- Both brands typically avoid corn, wheat, and soy in many of their mainstream recipes.
American Journey
American Journey is built around value-focused formulations: fewer product lines, fewer specialty claims, and straightforward “meat + carbs + produce + supplements” recipes.
- Meat-first positioning: Many American Journey recipes feature deboned meat as the first ingredient (commonly chicken, beef, lamb, salmon).
- Grain-inclusive recipes: Often use grains like brown rice and oatmeal (useful for dogs who do better with grains or owners who prefer them).
- Grain-free recipes: Frequently rely on legumes (like peas/chickpeas) and potatoes/sweet potatoes as carbohydrate sources. (This is common across grain-free kibble, not unique to American Journey.)
- Made in the USA: Chewy notes its foods are manufactured in the U.S. with domestic and imported ingredients.
Takeaway: American Journey’s ingredient approach is simple and budget-friendly, with solid “meat first” recipes — but less specialization and fewer unique features than premium brands.
Blue Buffalo
Blue Buffalo’s ingredient identity is more “feature-driven”: broad formula variety, more niche options, and one signature add-in you’ll see across much of the dry lineup.
- Meat-first positioning + brand promises: Blue Buffalo highlights real deboned meat first and “no corn, wheat, or soy” across many formulas, and also emphasizes no chicken/poultry by-product meals in key lines like Life Protection.
- LifeSource Bits: Many Blue Buffalo dry recipes include LifeSource Bits, which the brand describes as “cold-formed” bits containing a blend of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants.
- Peas/legumes still appear in some grain-inclusive foods: Even in grain-inclusive recipes (like Life Protection Chicken & Brown Rice), you’ll still see ingredients like peas in the list, so it’s not a simple “grain-free = legumes” or “grain-inclusive = no legumes” situation.
Takeaway: Blue Buffalo offers more formula depth and more “features” per recipe (like LifeSource Bits), but the ingredient lists can be more complex, and some formulas still include legumes even when they’re not grain-free.
A Quick Note On Peas/Legumes And Grain-Free Diets
You’ll see peas and other legumes in many grain-free kibbles (and sometimes grain-inclusive ones). The FDA has been investigating a potential association between certain diets (often grain-free and legume-heavy) and canine dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), but the FDA also notes legumes have been used for years and are not considered inherently dangerous. If your dog has heart risk factors (or you’re unsure), it’s worth discussing diet choice with your vet.
American Journey vs Blue Buffalo Comparison Table
| Feature | American Journey | Blue Buffalo |
|---|---|---|
| Brand type | Chewy exclusive / house brand | Mainstream premium brand (owned by General Mills) |
| Best known for | Value-focused recipes with meat-first positioning | Huge formula variety + LifeSource Bits |
| Availability | Primarily sold through Chewy | Widely available (online + major retailers) |
| Manufacturing | Made in the USA at partner facilities (Kansas) | Company-owned U.S. facilities (MO and IN) |
| First ingredient | Often deboned meat or a meat meal (varies by recipe) | Typically deboned meat (varies by line) |
| Grain-free options | Yes | Yes (many formulas) |
| Grain-inclusive options | Yes | Yes |
| Limited-ingredient diets | Yes (smaller selection) | Yes (larger selection, multiple lines) |
| Breed-size targeting | Some large-breed options; fewer size-specific formulas | More size-specific options (including small-breed lines) |
| Signature “add-in” | More straightforward formulas (no signature component) | LifeSource Bits (vitamins/minerals/antioxidants) |
| Recall history | No publicly reported recalls to date | Multiple voluntary recalls/withdrawals (mainly 2007–2017) |
Bottom Line On Ingredients
- Choose Blue Buffalo if you want the widest ingredient variety, more specialty and limited-ingredient formulas, or options tailored to specific sizes, sensitivities, or protein preferences.
- Choose American Journey if you want simpler, meat-first recipes at a lower price, prefer straightforward ingredient lists, or are looking for a budget-friendly alternative without corn, wheat, or soy.
Range Of Formulas
A quality dog food brand should support dogs through every life stage, not just adulthood. Puppies, adults, and seniors all have different nutritional needs, and factors like breed size, activity level, and health considerations play a major role in choosing the right formula.
The strongest brands do this by offering:
- Life-stage nutrition with balanced protein, fat, and nutrients for growth, maintenance, and healthy aging
- Breed-size–specific recipes that account for metabolism, kibble size, and joint support
- Targeted formulas for common needs like sensitive digestion, skin and coat health, weight management, and mobility
So how do American Journey and Blue Buffalo compare when it comes to overall variety?
Formula Availability At A Glance
Blue Buffalo offers one of the widest selections on the market, with a large number of dry and wet dog food recipes spread across multiple product lines. Its lineup includes grain-free and grain-inclusive options, limited-ingredient diets, high-protein recipes, and formulas designed for specific sizes and health goals.
American Journey provides a more streamlined lineup, focusing on core life-stage nutrition with fewer product lines and less specialization. While the selection is smaller, it still covers grain-free and grain-inclusive diets, along with limited-ingredient recipes, at a more accessible price point.
In short:
- Blue Buffalo prioritizes variety and specialization
- American Journey prioritizes simplicity and value
To see which brand is the better fit for your dog, we’ll break down their offerings by life stage, starting with puppy formulas.
Puppy Formula Comparison
Puppy nutrition sets the foundation for growth, bone development, brain health, a strong immune system, and digestion. Puppies need higher protein and fat than adults, plus carefully balanced calcium and phosphorus, especially for large-breed puppies, where improper ratios can increase the risk of joint problems.
The strongest puppy food lineups offer:
- Life-stage–specific nutrition (not “all life stages” by default)
- Breed-size options, especially for large breeds
- Grain-inclusive and grain-free choices
- Clearly defined puppy formulas rather than scaled-down adult recipes
Here’s how American Journey and Blue Buffalo compare.
American Journey Puppy Formulas
American Journey offers a limited but focused puppy lineup, with options designed for general puppy growth rather than heavy specialization.
- Offers both grain-free and grain-inclusive puppy recipes
- Includes large-breed puppy formulas, which are important for controlled growth
- Uses real meat as the first ingredient across puppy recipes
- Does not offer small-breed–specific puppy formulas
- No targeted puppy diets for sensitivities, digestion, or specialty needs
Best for: owners looking for a simple, affordable puppy food with solid ingredients and no unnecessary add-ons.
Blue Buffalo Puppy Formulas
Blue Buffalo offers one of the most extensive puppy selections on the market, spread across several product lines.
- Puppy recipes across multiple lines (Life Protection, Wilderness, Basics, Freedom, Baby BLUE)
- Grain-inclusive and grain-free options
- Small-breed and large-breed puppy formulas
- Limited-ingredient puppy recipes for sensitivities
- Wet puppy food and puppy treats available
- More protein-forward options for higher-energy puppies
Best for: owners who want size-specific, sensitivity-aware, or specialty puppy formulas — or who prefer more options to fine-tune nutrition.
Winner: Blue Buffalo
While American Journey covers the basics well, Blue Buffalo clearly offers more puppy-specific formulas, including small-breed options, limited-ingredient recipes, and wet puppy food. For puppies with specific needs — or owners who want more control over formulation details — Blue Buffalo provides more flexibility.
That said, American Journey remains a solid budget-friendly choice for healthy puppies without special dietary concerns.
Puppy Formula Top Pick: Blue Buffalo Life Protection Puppy Formula
View on Amazon | View on Chewy
Blue Buffalo’s Life Protection Puppy Formula focuses on steady, balanced growth rather than extreme protein levels or trendy add-ins. It combines real meat protein with digestible grains, making it a solid option for puppies that do best on a more traditional diet.
Available in chicken & brown rice and lamb & oatmeal, this formula gives owners flexibility — particularly for puppies that don’t tolerate chicken. Added DHA supports cognitive development, while omega fatty acids help maintain healthy skin and a developing coat. Blue Buffalo’s LifeSource Bits provide an extra blend of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants formulated to support immune health during early growth.
Like other Life Protection recipes, it avoids corn, wheat, soy, and poultry by-product meals, and uses a smaller kibble size designed for easier chewing by young dogs.
Key Features
- Real meat as the first ingredient
- Grain-inclusive formula
- DHA for brain and eye development
- Omega-3 & omega-6 fatty acids
- Antioxidants for immune support
- No corn, wheat, or soy
- Puppy-sized kibble for easier chewing
- 401 kcal per cup
- 27% protein, 16% fat, 5% fiber
Price
- $43.97 (15-lb bag)
Adult Formula Comparison
Adult dog food should focus on long-term maintenance, not growth or weight gain. At this stage, the goal is consistent energy, healthy digestion, and support for joints, skin, and coat — all while avoiding unnecessary calories.
Strong adult food lineups typically offer:
- Multiple protein options to allow rotation or address sensitivities
- Grain-free and grain-inclusive choices
- Breed-size–specific formulas or small-bite options
- Targeted recipes for weight management or common sensitivities
Here’s how American Journey and Blue Buffalo compare for adult dogs.
American Journey Adult Formulas
American Journey’s adult lineup is built around core nutrition and value, with a focus on covering common needs rather than niche specialization.
- Offers a mix of grain-free and grain-inclusive adult recipes
- Multiple protein sources, including chicken, beef, lamb, and salmon
- Includes limited-ingredient diets for dogs with simpler sensitivities
- Some large-breed formulas available
- Fewer small-breed or size-specific options
- No veterinary or condition-specific lines
Best for: adult dogs without complex dietary needs, and owners who want solid ingredients at a lower price without paying for specialty branding.
Blue Buffalo Adult Formulas
Blue Buffalo’s adult selection is one of the largest on the market, spanning several distinct product lines with varying nutritional philosophies.
- Extensive range of grain-free and grain-inclusive recipes
- Wide selection of protein sources and novel proteins
- Small-breed, large-breed, and healthy weight formulas
- Targeted lines for skin & coat, digestion, mobility, and weight management
- Includes both standard retail formulas and veterinary-exclusive diets
Best for: owners who want maximum flexibility, size-specific options, or formulas tailored to particular health goals.
Winner: American Journey
American Journey wins for adult dogs based on value and simplicity. It covers the most common adult needs — grain-free, grain-inclusive, limited-ingredient, and large-breed formulas — with meat-first recipes at a lower price point. For healthy adult dogs without specialized dietary requirements, American Journey offers a more practical everyday option.
Blue Buffalo still stands out for variety and specialty formulas, but for straightforward adult nutrition, American Journey delivers better value per bag.
Adult Formula Top Pick: American Journey Grain-Free Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe
American Journey’s Salmon & Sweet Potato recipe is a fish-first, grain-free option that balances solid ingredient quality with an accessible price. Deboned salmon is the first ingredient, supported by poultry meals that raise protein levels and contribute naturally occurring glucosamine and chondroitin.
Sweet potatoes, peas, and chickpeas replace traditional grains, while salmon oil and flaxseed supply omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids for skin and coat support. Because fish is the primary protein and common grains are excluded, this formula can be a good choice for some dogs with food sensitivities or recurring skin issues, particularly those that don’t do well on chicken-forward diets.
Manufactured in the U.S., it offers a moderate calorie density that works well for many adult dogs when portions are managed.
Key Features
- Deboned salmon as the first ingredient
- Grain-free formula
- No corn, wheat, soy, or poultry by-product meals
- Omega-3 & omega-6 fatty acids for skin and coat health
- Naturally occurring glucosamine and chondroitin
- Made in the USA
- 390 calories per cup
- 32% protein, 14% fat, 5% fiber
Price
- $39.99 (12-lb bag)
Senior Formulas Comparison
Senior dogs have different nutritional priorities than younger adults. As dogs age, they often benefit from moderate protein levels, controlled calories, and added joint support, along with formulas that are easier to digest.
Strong senior food lineups typically offer:
- Clearly labeled senior formulas (not just “all life stages”)
- Joint-support nutrients like glucosamine and chondroitin
- Controlled fat and calories to help manage weight
- Options that support mobility, digestion, and overall aging health
Here’s how American Journey and Blue Buffalo compare for senior dogs.
American Journey Senior Formulas
American Journey offers a small but straightforward senior lineup.
- Senior-specific recipes available in grain-free and grain-inclusive options
- No small-breed or large-breed senior formulas
- Higher glucosamine and chondroitin levels in some grain-free recipes compared to many competitors
- Fewer protein choices and no targeted senior diets for digestion, weight, or cognition
Best for: healthy senior dogs whose main needs are joint support and simple nutrition, especially when budget is a consideration.
Blue Buffalo Senior Formulas
Blue Buffalo provides a broader senior selection, spread across multiple product lines.
- Senior formulas in Life Protection, Wilderness, Freedom, and Basics lines
- Grain-free and grain-inclusive options
- Small-breed and large-breed senior formulas available
- More formulas with controlled calories and added functional nutrients
- Senior wet food options also available
Best for: senior dogs who need size-specific formulas, calorie control, or more tailored nutrition as they age.
Winner: Blue Buffalo
While American Journey offers a few solid senior recipes, including some with high joint-support nutrients, Blue Buffalo provides more options tailored to senior dogs, including breed-size formulas and calorie-controlled recipes. For aging dogs with changing needs, that added flexibility makes a meaningful difference.
American Journey remains a reasonable choice for uncomplicated senior diets, but Blue Buffalo offers more tools to fine-tune senior nutrition.
Senior Formula Top Pick: Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Senior
View on Amazon | View on Chewy
Blue Buffalo’s Life Protection Senior recipe is built for older dogs transitioning into lower energy needs, without sacrificing protein quality. Real chicken is the first ingredient, paired with digestible whole grains to support everyday nutrition as metabolism slows.
This formula includes added glucosamine to help support aging joints, along with omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids for skin and coat maintenance. Ingredients like L-carnitine help support healthy weight management in less active seniors, while taurine contributes to overall heart health. Blue Buffalo’s signature LifeSource Bits add a blend of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants designed to support immune function in older dogs.
With a lower calorie count per cup, this recipe works well for seniors who need help maintaining a healthy weight without aggressive calorie restriction.
Key Features
- Real chicken as the first ingredient
- Grain-inclusive recipe
- Added glucosamine for joint support
- Omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids for skin and coat
- L-Carnitine for slowing metabolism
- Taurine for heart health
- 343 kcal per cup
- 18% protein, 10% fat, 7% fiber
Price
- $43.97 (15-lb bag)
Wet Food Comparison
Wet dog food can be used as a full meal, topper, or rotation option, especially for picky eaters, seniors, or dogs that benefit from extra moisture in their diet. A strong wet food lineup should cover multiple life stages, offer varied proteins, and include both grain-free and grain-inclusive options.
Here’s how American Journey and Blue Buffalo compare.
American Journey Wet Food
American Journey’s wet food selection is small and straightforward, designed to complement its dry food lineup rather than serve as a full replacement.
- Limited number of wet recipes, primarily for adult dogs
- Includes some limited-ingredient options
- No clearly defined puppy- or senior-specific wet formulas
- No breed-size targeting
- Most recipes are grain-free
Best for: owners who want a simple wet topper to pair with American Journey kibble, or dogs that do well on uncomplicated recipes.
Blue Buffalo Wet Food
Blue Buffalo offers one of the largest wet food selections available, spread across multiple product lines.
- Wet recipes for puppies, adults, and seniors
- Options for small and large breeds
- Both grain-free and grain-inclusive formulas
- Wide variety of proteins and textures
- Includes limited-ingredient and sensitivity-focused wet foods
Best for: dogs that rely on wet food as a primary diet, picky eaters, or owners who want maximum flexibility when rotating proteins or textures.
Winner: Blue Buffalo
Blue Buffalo wins the wet food category by a wide margin. While American Journey’s wet foods work well as occasional toppers, Blue Buffalo offers far more choices across life stages, sizes, and dietary needs, making it the better option for dogs that regularly eat wet food or require more tailored nutrition.
Wet Formula Top Pick: Blue Buffalo Homestyle Wet Dog Food
View on Amazon | View on Chewy
Blue Buffalo’s Homestyle line is designed for owners who want a traditional, grain-inclusive wet food made with recognizable ingredients. Real meat is the first ingredient in each recipe, paired with wholesome grains and a short list of supporting ingredients that work well for dogs who don’t need highly specialized formulas.
The lamb recipe is often a good fit for dogs with food sensitivities or owners looking to rotate away from chicken, while options like chicken, beef, and turkey make it easy to switch proteins without changing brands. The texture and nutrient balance allow it to work as either a standalone meal or a moisture-rich topper mixed with dry food.
With added fruits and vegetables for nutritional support, Homestyle is a practical choice for dogs that do better on simple, hearty wet foods rather than pâté-style or prescription formulas.
Key Features
- Real meat as the first ingredient
- Grain-inclusive recipe
- Available in multiple protein options
- Suitable as a full meal or kibble topper
- Includes fruits and vegetables for added nutrients
- 478 kcal per cup
- 8.5% protein, 7% fat, 1.3% fiber
Price
- Check Amazon for availability (12.5-oz can (Pack of 12))
Our Personal Experience With American Journey And Blue Buffalo
We discovered that our 35-pound mixed breed, Barley, is allergic to poultry when doing an elimination diet to hopefully resolve his anal gland issues. We made the switch to a fish-based kibble by Blue Buffalo, and it worked well, but was expensive. We found a very similar formulation from American Journey and transitioned him onto that successfully because the price was significantly lower. Today, both of our dogs love their American Journey Salmon, Brown Rice & Vegetables Recipe.
– Michelle Schenker, rescue pup parent
Final Verdict: American Journey vs. Blue Buffalo
American Journey and Blue Buffalo both focus on meat-first recipes and avoid common fillers, but they’re built for different priorities.
American Journey is the stronger choice for value and simplicity. Its streamlined lineup delivers solid nutrition — especially for adult dogs — at a lower price, making it a practical long-term option for healthy dogs without specialized needs.
Blue Buffalo stands out for variety and flexibility. With more puppy, senior, and wet food options — plus size-specific and limited-ingredient formulas — it offers more ways to tailor a diet as your dog’s needs change.
If your dog does best on straightforward, budget-friendly food, American Journey is often the better fit. If you need more formula choices or life-stage flexibility, Blue Buffalo provides more options.
The Bottom Line
American Journey → Best for healthy adult dogs and owners who want simple, meat-first nutrition at a lower cost.
Blue Buffalo → Best for puppies, seniors, wet food variety, and dogs that benefit from greater ingredient and formula flexibility.
Looking For Other Healthy Dog Food Options?
While both brands offer quality dog chow, some dogs do better on different diets. If your pup has weight issues, sensitivities, or other medical needs, you may want to explore alternatives like fresh dog food, air-dried dog food, or freeze-dried dog food. Be sure to talk with your veterinarian before switching. Whatever you choose, always check the ingredient list and guaranteed analysis to ensure it meets your dog’s nutritional needs.
Have you tried American Journey or Blue Buffalo for your dog? We’d love to hear what worked — or didn’t — in the comments below, and which dog food brands you’d recommend to other dog owners.
