Blue Buffalo vs. Hill’s Science Diet: A Dog Food Showdown

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Here’s how it works.

Trying to choose the right food for your dog? Two of the most recognizable brands you’ll see are Blue Buffalo and Hill’s Science Diet. One emphasizes ingredient-focused, natural recipes with a wide range of options, while the other relies on decades of veterinary research and science-backed nutrition.

We compare recall history, ingredients, and available formulas so you can decide which is the better fit for your dog’s needs. Because the proper diet can mean better digestion, healthier skin and coat, and long-term wellness, this breakdown covers everything you need to know in our Blue Buffalo vs. Hill’s Science Diet comparison.

Puppy Top Pick	Adult Top Pick	Senior Top Pick
Blue Buffalo	Hill’s Science Diet	Blue Buffalo
View on Amazon	View on Amazon	View on Amazon
View on Chewy	View on Chewy	View on Chewy
Read Review	Read Review	Read Review

Brand Histories

Finding healthy dog food that meets your pup’s needs is a big task, and choosing between brands can be challenging. Understanding where a dog food brand comes from can help explain how it formulates its recipes — and who those recipes are designed for.

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo was founded in 2003 by the Bishop family in Connecticut after the loss of their dog, Blue, to cancer. The family built the brand around a simple idea: make dog food with real meat and recognizable, healthy ingredients, without artificial flavors, preservatives, or by-products.

Today, Blue Buffalo is one of the largest natural pet food brands in the U.S., offering a wide range of formulas, including:

• Grain-free and grain-inclusive options
• Limited-ingredient recipes
• High-protein and specialty diets

The brand emphasizes transparency, ingredient education, and variety, which appeals to owners who want more control over what goes into their dog’s bowl.

Hill’s Science Diet

Hill’s Science Diet is produced by Hill’s Pet Nutrition, a company with roots in veterinary medicine dating back to the 1930s. The brand began when a veterinarian developed a therapeutic diet to help manage kidney disease in dogs, laying the foundation for Hill’s research-driven approach to pet nutrition.

Science Diet focuses on science-backed nutrition designed to support:

• Specific life stages
• Breed sizes
• Common health concerns

Its formulas are developed with veterinarians and nutritionists and are frequently recommended in veterinary clinics, prioritizing consistency and clinical research over ingredient trends.

Product Recall History

When the quality or the safety of products doesn’t meet expectations, the pet food company voluntarily recalls, or the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) withdraws the affected products.

Recalls don’t automatically mean a brand is “bad” — they’re most useful as a window into a company’s quality control and how quickly it responds when something goes wrong. Below are the most notable, publicly documented recalls for each brand.

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo has had several voluntary recalls/market withdrawals since 2003. Using the FDA website and the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), here is a brief history of these recalls:

• April 2007 (industry-wide): Blue Buffalo was among many brands affected by the melamine contamination crisis tied to contaminated ingredients used across the pet food industry.
• October 2010: Voluntary recall tied to potentially elevated vitamin D levels (a nutrient that can be dangerous at high levels).
• November 2015: Voluntary recall of some chew bones due to potential Salmonella contamination.
• May 2016: Voluntary recall of a limited amount of dry food due to excess moisture, which can increase mold risk.
• March 2017: Voluntary recall of one lot of canned food due to potentially elevated naturally occurring beef thyroid hormones.
• June 2017: Voluntary recall of certain cup-style wet foods due to foil seal quality issues (no illnesses reported in that notice).

Hill’s Science Diet

Hill’s (Science Diet and some Prescription Diet products) has had fewer widely cited recalls, with the major ones being:

• June 2014: Hill’s voluntarily recalled 62 bags of Science Diet Adult Small & Toy Breed dry dog food due to potential Salmonella contamination.
• November 2015: The company initiated a market withdrawal of several soft food flavors due to labeling issues. No consumer issues were ever reported.
• January 31, 2019: Hill’s voluntarily recalled select canned dog foods for excessive vitamin D.
• March 20, 2019: Hill’s expanded that recall to additional products/lot codes, tied to the same vitamin premix issue.

What’s Really In The Bowl? Ingredients Compared

Ingredients are where Blue Buffalo and Hill’s Science Diet differ the most, and understanding those differences matters more than picking a “better” label.

Blue Buffalo focuses on ingredient-forward, natural-style recipes, emphasizing real meat, variety, and options like grain-free or limited-ingredient diets. Hill’s Science Diet takes a nutrition-first, research-driven approach, prioritizing digestibility, consistency, and clinically formulated nutrient profiles — even if that means using ingredients some owners question.

Neither approach is inherently wrong. The better choice depends on your dog’s health needs, sensitivities, and how much flexibility you want in ingredient selection.

Blue Buffalo: Ingredient Variety & Natural Positioning

Blue Buffalo emphasizes recognizable ingredients and offers one of the widest selections in this comparison.

Key ingredient traits include:

• Deboned meat is typically the first ingredient, such as chicken, beef, or fish
• A wide selection of protein sources, including poultry-free and novel proteins (rabbit, venison, duck, etc.)
• Both grain-inclusive and grain-free formulas available
• Grain-free recipes commonly use peas and lentils as carbohydrate sources
• No by-products, artificial flavors, or artificial preservatives
• Added vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants through LifeSource Bits

This approach appeals to owners who want flexibility, ingredient transparency, or options for dogs with food sensitivities or sensitive stomachs, especially those needing grain-free or limited-ingredient diets.

Hill’s Science Diet: Nutrition Science Over Ingredient Trends

Hill’s Science Diet focuses less on ingredient marketing and more on nutrient balance and clinical research.

Typical ingredient characteristics include:

• Animal-based proteins, most often chicken or lamb
• Grain-inclusive formulas using ingredients like corn, wheat, and rice
• Use of meat by-products, which can consist of nutrient-dense organ meats
• Added vitamins, minerals, and preservatives to meet precise nutritional targets
• Fewer legumes and no emphasis on grain-free formulas

This formulation style aligns with current veterinary guidance and is often recommended for dogs that do best on highly digestible, consistent diets.

Blue Buffalo vs Hill’s Science Diet: Ingredient Comparison Table

Feature	Blue Buffalo	Hill’s Science Diet
Protein Focus	Real meat emphasized	Balanced animal protein sources
First Ingredient	Typically deboned meat	Often meat or meat meal
By-Products Used	No	Yes
Grain-Free Options	Yes (many formulas)	Very limited
Grain-Inclusive Options	Yes	Yes
Common Grains	Oatmeal, brown rice	Corn, wheat, rice
Legumes (peas/lentils)	Common in grain-free lines	Rare
Formulation Approach	Ingredient variety & natural positioning	Veterinary science & clinical nutrition

Range of Formulas

A quality dog food brand should support dogs through every life stage, not just adulthood. Puppies, adults, and seniors all have different nutritional needs, and factors like breed size, activity level, and health concerns play a significant role in choosing the right formula.

The best brands step up by offering:

• Life stage nutrition with balanced protein, fat, and nutrients for growth, maintenance, and healthy aging
• Breed-size–specific recipes that account for metabolism, kibble size, and joint support
• Targeted formulas for common needs like sensitive digestion, skin and coat health, weight management, and mobility

So how do Blue Buffalo and Hill’s Science Diet compare when it comes to variety?

Formula Availability at a Glance

• Blue Buffalo offers one of the widest selections on the market, with 90+ dry dog food recipes across multiple product lines. Its lineup includes grain-free and grain-inclusive options, limited-ingredient diets, high-protein recipes, and veterinary-formulated foods.
• Hill’s Science Diet provides a more streamlined but highly focused selection, with 40+ dry dog food recipes designed to support specific life stages, breed sizes, and common health needs. Hill’s also offers its Prescription Diet line, which requires veterinary authorization and is formulated for medical conditions.

To see which brand is the best fit for your dog, let’s break down their formulas by life stage, starting with puppies.

Puppy Formulas Comparison

The puppy stage (up to 12–18 months, depending on breed) is one of the most important phases in a dog’s life. Nutrition during this window supports bone development, muscle growth, brain function, and immune health, setting the stage for lifelong wellness.

Puppies generally need:

• Higher protein and fat to fuel growth
• DHA and omega fatty acids for brain and eye development
• Carefully balanced calcium and phosphorus, especially for large breeds

Here’s how Blue Buffalo and Hill’s Science Diet compare when it comes to puppy nutrition.

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo takes a more ingredient-forward and flexible approach, offering a much wider range of puppy formulas.

• 15+ puppy dry food recipes across multiple product lines
• Grain-inclusive and grain-free options available
• Recipes tailored for small, large, and giant breed puppies
• Multiple protein sources, including chicken, lamb, fish, and poultry-free options
• Includes DHA and omega fatty acids for cognitive and visual development
• Select lines offer limited-ingredient and sensitive-stomach options
• LifeSource Bits added for extra vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants

This variety makes Blue Buffalo appealing for puppies with food sensitivities, picky appetites, or owners who want more control over ingredients.

Hill’s Science Diet

This brand offers a streamlined, research-driven lineup of puppy foods focused on digestibility and balanced growth.

• 10+ puppy formulas across dry and wet food
• Primarily grain-inclusive recipes
• Chicken is the main protein in most formulas, with a few lamb-based options
• Breed-size–specific options for small, medium, and large breed puppies
• Sensitive stomach & skin puppy formula available (salmon-based)
• Added DHA from fish oil to support brain and eye development
• No grain-free puppy formulas and limited alternative protein choices

Hill’s puppy foods are often recommended by veterinarians, particularly for owners who want a simple, science-backed approach without having to navigate dozens of options.

Puppy Formula Top Pick: Blue Buffalo Life Protection Puppy Formula

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

Blue Buffalo’s Life Protection Puppy Formula is designed to support healthy growth with a balance of real meat protein, wholesome grains, and targeted nutrients. Available in chicken & brown rice or lamb & oatmeal, it offers options for puppies that may not tolerate chicken well.

This recipe includes DHA for brain development, omega fatty acids for skin and coat health, and antioxidant-rich LifeSource Bits to support a developing immune system — all without corn, wheat, soy, or by-products.

Key Features

• Real meat as the first ingredient
• Grain-inclusive formula
• DHA for brain and eye development
• Omega-3 & omega-6 fatty acids
• Antioxidants for immune support
• No corn, wheat, or soy
• Puppy-sized kibble for easier chewing
• 401 kcal per cup
• 27% protein, 16% fat, 5% fiber

Price

• $43.97 (15-lb bag)

Adult Formulas Comparison

Most dogs spend the majority of their lives in the adult stage, typically from 1 to 7 years of age. Adult dog food should provide balanced nutrition to maintain lean muscle, healthy joints, steady energy levels, and long-term organ health without excess calories.

Key adult nutrition priorities include:

• Adequate protein to maintain muscle
• Moderate fat levels for energy without weight gain
• Support for joints, digestion, and skin & coat health

Here’s how Blue Buffalo and Hill’s Science Diet compare for adult dogs.

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo offers a much broader adult lineup, emphasizing ingredient choice and dietary flexibility.

• 70+ adult dry food recipes across multiple product lines
• Grain-inclusive and grain-free options
• Recipes tailored for small, medium, large, and giant breeds
• Wider protein selection, including chicken, beef, lamb, fish, and poultry-free recipes
• Limited-ingredient and sensitive-stomach formulas available
• Healthy weight, high-protein, and life-stage–specific options
• Added antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals via LifeSource Bits

This variety makes Blue Buffalo especially appealing to dogs with food sensitivities, dogs with protein preferences, and owners who want greater ingredient control.

Science Diet

Hill’s Science Diet shines when it comes to targeted adult nutrition and condition-specific formulas.

• 25+ adult dry food recipes
• Breed-size–specific formulas for small, medium, and large dogs
• Primarily grain-inclusive recipes
• Protein sources are mostly chicken or lamb
• Wide range of condition-focused options, including:
  • Weight management
  • Sensitive stomach & skin
  • Joint and mobility support
  • Oral care formulas
• Added nutrients like glucosamine, omega fatty acids, and antioxidants
• Only one grain-free adult formula (for sensitive stomach & skin)

Hill’s adult foods are often a go-to for dogs that need digestive consistency or targeted support without stepping into prescription diets.

Adult Formula Top Pick: Hill’s Science Diet Hill’s Science Diet Adult Sensitive Stomach & Skin

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

This formula is designed for adult dogs with digestive sensitivity, food intolerance, or chronic skin and coat issues. It uses highly digestible ingredients and targeted nutrients to support gut health and improve coat condition — without a veterinary prescription.

The grain-inclusive chicken recipe is one of Hill’s best sellers, while the salmon option provides an alternative protein for dogs that don’t tolerate chicken well. It’s also available in a grain-free formula and ones for large and small breeds.

Key Features

• Highly digestible ingredients for sensitive stomachs
• Prebiotic fiber to support gut microbiome health
• Omega-6 fatty acids and vitamin E for skin & coat
• Grain-inclusive
• Veterinarian-recommended for digestive and skin support
• 382 kcal per cup
• 20% protein, 13% fat, 4% fiber

Price

• $57.99 (15.5-lb bag)

Senior Formulas Comparison

Most dogs are considered seniors between 7 and 9 years old, though large breeds may reach this stage sooner. As dogs age, their nutritional needs shift toward joint support, easier digestion, and controlled calorie intake to maintain a healthy weight and mobility.

Senior diets should focus on:

• Moderate protein to maintain muscle without overtaxing aging organs
• Lower calories and fat to prevent weight gain
• Added glucosamine and chondroitin for joint health
• Antioxidants to support immune function

Here’s how Blue Buffalo and Hill’s Science Diet compare for senior dogs.

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo offers a broader range of senior-specific formulas, with greater flexibility in sizes and dietary needs.

• 15 senior dry food recipes across multiple product lines
• Grain-inclusive and grain-free options
• Formulas tailored for small and large senior dogs
• Multiple protein sources, including poultry-free options
• Added glucosamine and chondroitin, with higher levels in large-breed recipes
• Includes antioxidants and omega fatty acids for aging immune systems and joint health

This wider selection makes Blue Buffalo a better option for seniors with mobility concerns, food sensitivities, or size-specific needs.

Hill’s Science Diet

Hill’s Science Diet offers a targeted, research-driven lineup for senior dogs, with most formulas centered around dogs aged 7 years and older. Rather than providing a wide variety of senior diets, Hill’s focuses on digestibility, vitality, and age-related wellness, especially for dogs beginning to show early signs of aging.

• Senior dry food options primarily fall under Adult 7+ and Senior Vitality 7+ formulas
• Size-specific options available, including Small & Mini senior recipes
• Primarily grain-inclusive diets, avoiding grain-free formulations
• Protein sources are mostly chicken-based across the senior lineup
• Formulas emphasize:
  • Digestive support with easy-to-digest ingredients
  • Energy, alertness, and interaction support (notably in Senior Vitality recipes)
  • Skin and coat health via vitamin E and omega-6 fatty acids

Joint support ingredients may be included, but Hill’s does not consistently publish clear glucosamine or chondroitin levels across all senior formulas, making direct comparison more difficult.

Senior Formula Top Pick: Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Senior

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

This senior formula is designed to support healthy aging with balanced protein, controlled fat, and targeted joint nutrients. It’s especially well-suited for older dogs that still need quality protein but benefit from added mobility and immune support.

Key Features

• Real chicken as the first ingredient
• Grain-inclusive recipe
• Added glucosamine for joint support
• Omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids for skin and coat
• L-Carnitine for slowing metabolism
• Taurine for heart health
• 343 kcal per cup
• 18% protein, 10% fat, 7% fiber

Price

• $43.97 (15-lb bag)

Wet Food Comparison

Wet dog food can be a great addition to your dog’s diet, whether it’s used as a full meal or mixed with kibble for added moisture and flavor. It’s especially helpful for picky eaters, senior dogs, and dogs that need extra hydration.

When comparing wet food options, variety and life-stage coverage matter just as much as ingredients.

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo offers a much wider wet food lineup, covering nearly every life stage, size, and dietary preference.

• 100+ wet food recipes across multiple product lines
• Options for puppies, adults, and seniors
• Both grain-inclusive and grain-free wet foods available
• Broad protein variety, including chicken, beef, lamb, turkey, fish, and poultry-free options
• Includes classic pâtés, hearty stews, and limited-ingredient recipes
• Formulated to work as a complete meal or topper

This range makes Blue Buffalo wet food especially appealing for dogs with food sensitivities, changing appetites, or owners who like rotating proteins and textures.

Science Diet

Hill’s Science Diet offers a more limited but focused selection of wet dog foods designed to complement its dry formulas.

• 50+ wet food recipes, depending on availability
• Options for puppies, adults, and seniors
• Primarily grain-inclusive formulas
• Protein sources are mostly chicken, turkey, or beef
• Several recipes formulated for sensitive stomachs or weight management
• Consistent nutrient profiles that align with Science Diet dry foods

Hill’s wet foods are often chosen by owners who want predictable nutrition and easy pairing with their dog’s existing Science Diet kibble, rather than broad flavor variety.

Wet Formula Top Pick: Blue Buffalo Homestyle Wet Dog Food

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

Blue Buffalo’s Homestyle Recipe is one of the brand’s most popular wet food lines, made with real meat as the first ingredient and a simple, recognizable ingredient list. The lamb recipe is a strong option for dogs with sensitivities, while other flavors like chicken, beef, and turkey offer easy rotation.

Key Features

• Real meat as the first ingredient
• Grain-inclusive recipe
• Available in multiple protein options
• Suitable as a full meal or kibble topper
• Includes fruits and vegetables for added nutrients
• 478 kcal per cup
• 8.5% protein, 7% fat, 1.3% fiber

Price

• (12.5-oz can (Pack of 12))

Final Verdict: Blue Buffalo vs. Hill’s Science Diet

Both Blue Buffalo and Hill’s Science Diet are well-established, reputable dog food brands, but they serve very different types of dog owners — and dogs.

Hill’s Science Diet stands out for its health-focused, vet-developed formulas, especially for adult and senior dogs that need targeted nutrition for digestion, skin issues, weight management, or mobility. Its streamlined lineup prioritizes consistency and clinical balance over ingredient variety, making it a common recommendation in veterinary clinics.

Blue Buffalo, on the other hand, shines when it comes to variety and flexibility. With a much broader selection of puppy, adult, senior, and wet food formulas — including grain-free, limited-ingredient, and poultry-free options — Blue Buffalo gives owners more control over ingredients and dietary preferences.

If your dog has a specific health concern, chronic sensitivity, or does best on a predictable, vet-backed diet, Hill’s Science Diet is often the safer choice. But for healthy dogs, picky eaters, or owners who want more ingredient-forward options and life-stage flexibility, Blue Buffalo offers more ways to customize your dog’s diet.

The Bottom Line

Hill’s Science Diet →
Best for adult and senior dogs with specific health needs, sensitive digestion, or owners who prefer vet-developed, grain-inclusive nutrition. Reliable, widely available, and clinically focused.

Blue Buffalo →
Best for puppies, seniors, wet food variety, and dogs that need grain-free, limited-ingredient, or alternative protein options. More flexible, ingredient-forward, and lifestyle-driven.

Beyond Kibble & Cans

Dog nutrition continues to evolve, and many pet parents are now exploring fresh dog food, air-dried dog food, and customized options for added convenience and nutritional diversity. Brands like The Farmer’s Dog, Ollie, Spot & Tango, and Badlands Ranch offer alternatives that go beyond traditional kibble and canned food. We’ve reviewed and tested these options to help you decide if one might be right for your dog.

Have you tried Blue Buffalo or Hill’s Science Diet for your pup? We’d love to hear what worked — or didn’t — in the comments below, and which dog food brands you’d recommend to other readers.