When To Put A Dog Down: 6 Gut-Wrenching Signs It’s Time To Say Goodbye

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Here’s how it works.

Your dog won’t cry, but they will tell you when they’re ready. Maybe they’re still eating. Maybe they wag when you walk in. But deep down, something feels different… and it’s breaking your heart.

Making the decision to put a dog down is the most heartbreaking call a pet parent ever makes. But sometimes, the most loving thing you can do is also the hardest. These are the gut-wrenching signs that it might be time to say goodbye, and how to know for sure.

6 Subtle Signs Your Dog Is Suffering

In some cases, it may be obvious that your pet won’t recover from an injury or serious illness and needs to be put to sleep to avoid unnecessary suffering.

But not all suffering is loud. Dogs are experts at hiding pain; it’s part of their survival instinct. They don’t whimper or cry like we might expect.

Instead, the signs are sometimes quiet, easy to miss, and often mistaken for the natural effects of aging or simply “just slowing down.” But these subtle shifts could be your dog’s way of saying, “I’m not okay.”

1. They Stop Greeting You at the Door

That tail-thumping, body-wiggling excitement? Gone. Maybe they stay curled in their bed when you come home. Maybe they glance up but don’t move. If your dog no longer rushes to see you, or doesn’t seem to care if you’re there, it could be emotional or physical exhaustion setting in.

2. They Avoid Your Eyes or Stare Into Space

Eye contact is one of the deepest ways dogs connect with us. When they start turning their head away, staring into corners, or zoning out, it’s often a sign of pain, confusion, or shutting down emotionally. Some owners describe it as if their dog is “already halfway gone.”

3. They Seek Out Strange, Isolated Spots

Sleeping in the bathtub. Hiding behind furniture. Lying under the bed instead of next to you. Dogs will often isolate themselves when they’re in pain or preparing to let go. If your social pup suddenly wants to be alone, it’s time to take notice.

4. Their Breathing Seems… Different

Even if they’re not running or playing, you might hear fast panting, shallow breaths, or irregular sighs. Labored breathing can signal discomfort, internal issues, or the early stages of organ failure. You may not realize it right away until you’re up close and hear the subtle strain in every breath.

5. They Stop Caring About the Things They Used to Love

That favorite toy? Ignored. Walks? Skipped. They might still get up to follow you around the house, but they’re not engaged. You may see hesitation in their movements or just a general “checked out” vibe. Joy is one of the first things to disappear when a dog is hurting.

6. They’re Here, But Not Really Themselves

Maybe they’re still eating. Maybe their tail twitches when you say their name. But deep down, you know something’s different. Their spark is gone. Their rhythm is off. And your gut is telling you that your best friend is slipping away.

Coming up next: what it really means when a dog is still eating and wagging, but suffering anyway.

Still Eating, Still Wagging, But Still Suffering?

One of the hardest parts of deciding when to put a dog down is the mixed signals. Your dog still eats. Maybe they wag their tail when you say their name. So… how could they be ready to go?

Here’s the truth: Dogs are wired to hide pain. They’ll do their best to seem “normal” because they don’t want to show weakness or worry you. That means a wagging tail or a bit of appetite doesn’t always mean they’re okay. Sometimes it just means they’re trying.

Eating isn’t the same as thriving. Your dog might still nibble at food, or even get excited for treats, but that doesn’t mean their body is working the way it should.

Many dogs eat out of habit or comfort, even as they struggle with pain, nausea, or fatigue. And some will keep eating right up until the very end.

The same goes for tail wagging. It might be a reflex or a brief moment of recognition, rather than a sign that they feel well. If your dog’s only moments of normalcy are tied to food or your presence, it could be a sign they’re pushing through pain to please you.

The real question isn’t, “Are they still eating?” It’s, “Are they still living well?”

• Do they enjoy walks or play?
• Are they resting comfortably, or do they struggle to get up?
• Are they having more bad days than good ones?
• Are they still connected, or just going through the motions?

If the answers lean toward decline, don’t wait for them to stop eating or collapse before making the call. By then, they may already be suffering in silence.

Coming up next: the Vet-Recommended Quality of Life Scale that gives you a clear, compassionate way to make this decision.

The Vet-Recommended Quality of Life Scale

If you’re noticing changes, especially if they’re piling up, it’s time to go beyond gut feelings and seek clarity. That’s where a quality of life scale can help.

Veterinarians often use a framework called the HHHHHMM Scale, created by Dr. Alice Villalobos. It breaks down your dog’s wellbeing into seven key areas:

Before you begin, take a deep breath. This isn’t a test, and there are no right or wrong answers. This is about noticing the little things that add up, rather than trying to convince yourself of anything. It’s to gently step back and see your dog’s life as it is right now, not how it used to be.

Think about the following:

1. Is My Dog In Pain?

Is your dog on pain medications or alternative therapies and still showing signs of discomfort or pain? Are you noticing signs indicating they are having trouble breathing normally?

Persistent whining, panting, an inability to get comfortable, and immobility could all indicate chronic pain.

2. Is My Pup Eating & Drinking Normally?

If your dog has lost their appetite and refuses to eat, you can try feeding them by hand. But if that doesn’t work, a feeding tube may be necessary to ensure that your pup gets adequate nutrition.

And if they’re not drinking much, contact your vet. Dogs can get dehydrated easily, so IV fluids may be necessary.

However, these aren’t good long-term solutions if your pup continues to refuse to eat and drink. Some owners ask,” Should I put my dog down if they’re still eating?” The answer again depends on your dog’s specific circumstances and medical condition. It is best to discuss this with your veterinarian.

3. Has My Dog’s Mobility Declined?

Is your dog able to get up and walk around fairly normally? Can you still take them on walks or take them out to relieve themselves? If not, they’ll need assistance with a harness or sling.

Is your dog stumbling a lot? If your pup has arthritis and joint problems, are medication and/or alternative therapies no longer helping with your dog’s mobility and pain? Consider how your dog’s immobility issues affect their happiness.

4. Are There Changes In My Dog’s Urination Or Defecation?

Is your pup unable to urinate or defecate? If so, please contact your veterinarian as soon as possible. Or has your dog developed fecal or urinary incontinence? Incontinence, particularly with a pet who’s unable to move away from the mess, is a big factor for many pet parents considering euthanasia.

5. Does My Dog Still Enjoy Interaction?

Does your pup seem happy and interested in interacting with you, your family members, and other pets? Are they still able to play and enjoy mental stimulation? Or are they isolating themselves from others and showing signs of stress, depression, anxiety, or even aggression?

Dogs are highly social, so if your dog isn’t interacting, it’s likely that they’re unhappy and suffering.

6. Are There More Bad Days Than Good Days?

Ask yourself if your dog is having more bad days than good days. If the bad days outnumber the good days, especially if your pup has several bad days in a row, then their quality of life is extremely poor.

Depending on your dog’s illness, bad days could involve a lot of vomiting, diarrhea, falling down, seizures, not eating or drinking, etc. And if your dog seems generally “checked out” of life, then it’s time to seriously consider euthanasia.

How to Use This Scale & Questions

• Track over several days for patterns
• Ask your vet to review it with you
• Compare it week to week if your dog is stable but aging

This tool isn’t meant to replace your instincts; it’s meant to support them. You know your dog better than anyone. But seeing the reality on paper can give you the clarity you need to make the most loving choice.

Coming up next: why sometimes, waiting too long is harder than letting go early.

Why Waiting Too Long Hurts More Than Letting Go Early

Most dog parents share the same fear: “What if I let go too soon?”

It’s a devastating thought that you might take away time your dog could’ve still enjoyed. So we wait. We hope for a rebound. We tell ourselves, “Let’s just give it another day.” And then another.

But here’s what often happens: the decline comes fast. One day they’re okay-ish… the next, they’re in crisis. Gasping. Panicked. In pain. And suddenly, instead of a peaceful goodbye, you’re racing to an emergency vet, making decisions through tears, fear, and regret.

Acting early isn’t giving up. It’s giving your dog the gift of peace. Choosing euthanasia before your dog is in visible, acute distress doesn’t mean you acted too soon. It means you spared them a traumatic final chapter.

Many vets will tell you the same thing: “Better a week too early than a day too late.” Here’s why early action can be the more loving choice:

• You Get to Plan a Calm, Gentle Goodbye. At home, on their bed, with their favorite blanket or meal.
• You Spare Them Panic. Dogs don’t understand ER visits or oxygen masks.
• You Avoid Emergency Suffering. Seizures, breathing failure, and collapse. These happen fast, and they’re terrifying for both of you.
• You Preserve the Dignity They Deserve.

There’s no perfect moment. But there is a window where love and timing meet, and your dog can leave this world feeling safe, held, and at peace. The goal isn’t to hold on as long as possible. It’s to let go before the pain outweighs the joy.

Coming up next: real stories from pet parents who faced this decision, and how they knew it was time.

When is it Time to Put a Dog Down? Our Experience

No one wants to make this decision. Even when the signs are there, even when the vet gently confirms what you already know, it still feels impossible. That’s why hearing from others who’ve walked this path can help.

I spoke to a Canine Journal team member who has shared her experience with me. Her story won’t make the decision easier. But they might make it feel a little less lonely.

My dog Bear, a black Lab, developed epilepsy when he was about 2 years old. This disease greatly impacted his life. However, we took great care to ensure he had an active, healthy, and happy life.

However, when he was close to 12 years old, it became clear he was going downhill. He was confused, tired, and having more intense seizures. After two very scary ones in a row, we knew we needed to make that heart-wrenching call.

After consulting with his veterinarian and doing some tests, it was confirmed that, sadly, he was not going to recover. We took him home and had a special last night, giving him a tasty meal of steak and, the next day, helping him on his final journey.

Having taken care of a special needs dog for so long, it was important to take that same level of care with him when making this end-of-life decision. Our top priority had always been to give him a good, safe life, and when that was no longer possible, we had to do what was best for him.

Working closely with his veterinarians and technicians throughout his life was key to keeping him healthy, managing his disease, and also pivotal when it came time to make the decision to put him down.

–Danielle DeGroot, A Rescue Dog Parent & Writer for Canine Journal

Consult With Your Veterinarian About When To Put A Dog Down

When is it time to put a dog down? This depends on each dog’s individual situation. Knowing when to euthanize a dog can be extremely challenging for many pet parents. While your veterinarian can’t make this decision for you, discussing your dog’s current health and quality of life can be a significant help.

It may be helpful to ask your veterinarian about any further treatment options available and their opinion on whether additional procedures or therapy would be beneficial for your pup’s daily well-being.

Your veterinarian will be able to provide you with an idea of the prognosis and progression of your dog’s medical issues. Even with further treatment, will your pup’s condition still only worsen with time?

And depending on your financial situation, you may need to weigh the costs associated with further treatment vs. the benefits for your pup.

Coming up next: what veterinarians look for (that most pet parents miss).

7 Signs Vets Look For That Most Owners Miss

You see your dog every day, which makes it hard to notice just how much they’ve changed. The decline often happens in inches, so slow, so subtle, that it doesn’t feel urgent until it’s undeniable. That’s why veterinarians rely on patterns, not just symptoms.

Here are the quiet red flags they often spot first and what they really mean:

1. Change in Posture or Gait

Vets watch how your dog stands, walks, and lies down. Is your dog slow to rise? Stiff after rest? Shuffling their feet instead of stepping clearly? These aren’t just signs of “getting older”. They often point to chronic pain or joint degeneration.

2. Subtle Weight Loss

A few pounds may not seem like much, especially if your dog is still eating. But vets see this as a warning sign; weight loss can indicate cancer, organ failure, or advanced metabolic disease, even if appetite seems okay.

3. Eye Expression & Responsiveness

Veterinarians often say, “I can see it in their eyes.” Dull, unfocused, or glassy eyes can signal cognitive decline, pain, or depression. If your dog seems “checked out,” it’s worth asking your vet what they see behind the eyes.

4. Muscle Loss or Body Condition Changes

Is your dog looking bony around the hips or shoulders? Even if they appear active, slow muscle wasting is a key sign that the body is struggling to sustain itself, especially in aging or terminally ill dogs.

5. Respiratory Rate at Rest

A vet may count your dog’s breaths while they sleep. Increased respiratory rate or effort while resting is a subtle but serious clue that something isn’t right, especially with heart or lung function.

6. Lack of Interest in Interaction

A big one that many owners misread. Your dog may still eat and walk… but if they no longer seek affection, avoid touch, or isolate themselves, that emotional withdrawal is significant. Vets see this not as behavioral, but physiological.

7. Owner’s Hesitation

Here’s the one that surprises people: when a pet parent says, “I don’t know if it’s time yet,” most vets don’t rush to answer. Instead, they look at how the pet is doing and how the owner is feeling. That hesitation often means you already see it… you just need help accepting it.

Veterinarians are trained to see what we overlook in our pets. If your vet says, “It might be time,” they’re not being cold or clinical; they’re simply being honest. They’re looking at your dog through the lens of function, comfort, and dignity, not just survival.

Coming up next: the questions to ask your vet if you’re still unsure… and how to get the clarity you need without second-guessing yourself later.

6 Questions to Ask Your Vet When You’re Not Sure

Even when the signs are there, even when your heart knows, it’s normal to want reassurance from someone you trust. That’s where your vet comes in.

But here’s the truth: most vets won’t say outright, “It’s time.” Not unless the situation is urgent. Instead, they’ll guide you with honesty, compassion, and clinical insight. The key is knowing what to ask and how to hear the answer behind their words.

Before your next visit, consider writing these questions down and taking them with you:

1. If This Were Your Dog, What Would You Do?

This question opens the door to real talk. You’re not asking for a diagnosis, you’re asking for personal, experience-based guidance. Most vets will answer honestly when framed this way.

2. Is My Dog in Pain Even If They’re Not Showing It?

Pain isn’t always obvious. This question invites your veterinarian to explain subtle signs you might be missing, such as posture, breathing, or withdrawal.

3. What Does the Road Ahead Look Like If We Do Nothing?

This helps you understand the real prognosis. Will things gradually decline, or could there be a sudden crisis? Knowing what to expect can make the decision clearer.

4. Are There Any Other Treatments That Could Improve Their Quality of Life?

You’re not asking about extending life, you’re asking about comfort. If the answer is no, that matters.

5. How Will I Know I’m Not Waiting Too Long?

This is one of the most important questions you can ask. Many vets will gently explain what the “too late” moment looks like and help you avoid it.

6. Can You Help Me Plan a Peaceful Goodbye If I Decide It’s Time?

This invites a calm, collaborative conversation about euthanasia logistics, including in-clinic vs. in-home options. Planning early gives you and your dog the best chance for a peaceful, loving goodbye.

Don’t be afraid to ask these questions and don’t apologize for needing answers. You are your dog’s voice. Your job isn’t to be certain. It’s to be compassionate, honest, and brave enough to ask what your dog can’t.

Coming up next: what to expect when that final day comes and how to make it as peaceful as possible for both of you.

What a Peaceful Goodbye Looks Like (Clinic vs. Home)

No matter how prepared you are, saying goodbye to your dog will never feel easy. But it can be peaceful. It can be loving. It can feel like the ultimate gift you give them, just as you gave them a good life.

When done with care, euthanasia is quick, gentle, and painless. Most dogs simply fall asleep in the arms of the people they love.

Still, many pet parents fear the process because they don’t know what to expect. Here’s what that final moment typically looks like, and how to choose the setting that feels right for you and your dog.

At the Veterinary Clinic

Many people choose to say goodbye at their vet’s office. It’s familiar, clinical, and the staff are trained to support both you and your dog through the process.

What to expect:

• You’ll usually be brought to a quiet, private room
• Your dog may receive a sedative first, to relax and ease anxiety
• Once your dog is calm, the euthanasia injection is given, usually into a vein
• It’s painless and works quickly, often within seconds
• You’ll have time to say goodbye before and after
• The clinic will walk you through cremation or burial options

This option is ideal for dogs who are comfortable at the vet or when medical equipment might be needed.

In this six-minute video, a veterinarian explains the process of pet euthanasia at his clinic. While your vet’s office may have a slightly different process, it gives you an idea of what to expect at your pup’s final vet visit.

At-Home Euthanasia

For some families, saying goodbye at home, on the couch, in the yard, in their bed, feels more personal. Many mobile veterinarians offer this service, and it can be deeply comforting for both pets and their owners.

What to expect:

• The vet comes to your home with everything needed
• You choose the space where your dog feels safest
• A sedative is given first, so your dog drifts into a relaxed sleep
• The euthanasia injection follows when you’re ready
• You can surround them with their favorite blanket, toy, or people
• Afterward, you have time to sit with them in peace

This option is ideal for dogs who are anxious, fearful of the vet, or very weak. It also allows other pets and family members to be present if you choose.

How to Prepare Emotionally

• Write your dog a goodbye letter
• Give them a “perfect day” beforehand – steak dinner, beach trip, extra cuddles
• Invite loved ones to say goodbye (in person or by video)
• Decide in advance if you want to stay during the procedure. Most people are glad they did, but it’s okay if you can’t

Above all, know this: you are not ending their life, you’re ending their suffering. You’re choosing peace over pain. Love over fear. Comfort over crisis.

Coming up next: how to plan your dog’s last day and create memories that stay with you long after they’re gone.

How to Plan a Beautiful Last Day With Your Dog: 7 Ways

If you’ve made the decision, or you’re close to it, you may be wondering: What do I do with our final day together?

There’s no perfect way to say goodbye. But there is a beautiful one. Whether you have a few hours or a whole weekend, this time can be filled with joy, comfort, and connection. Something your dog will feel and something you’ll always remember.

Here are some gentle, meaningful ways to turn your goodbye into a love story.

1. Let Them Eat Like Royalty

Forget the rules. Give them steak, chicken, peanut butter, whipped cream, ice cream – whatever made them happiest. If they have the appetite, make it a feast. If not, let them smell or lick their favorite treat. It’s about the experience, not the amount.

2. Go to Their Favorite Place

Whether it’s the beach, a quiet trail, the park bench where they always sat, or just the front porch, they’ll love being there with you. Even if they can’t walk far, just being in that space will feel familiar and safe.

3. Play Their Favorite Game

Fetch, tug, “find the treat,” or simply lie next to their favorite toy. If they don’t have the energy, let them watch. Let them feel included. Let them know it’s still their world.

4. Let Them Break the Rules

On the couch? In your bed? A bite of your burger? Yes, yes, and yes. Now’s the time to let them do the things you always said “not today” to. Today is theirs.

5. Surround Them With Love

Invite family and friends (in person or virtually) to say goodbye. Let your kids give them drawings, or whisper “thank you” in their ear. If they have a favorite animal buddy, let them spend one last time together.

6. Take Photos (If You Can)

You might not feel like it now, but a soft photo of them resting in the sunlight, or a selfie of you two snuggling… it may become one of your most treasured memories.

7. Make It About Presence, Not Perfection

There’s no pressure to do everything. Just be with them. Talk to them. Let them feel your calm, your warmth, your gratitude. Even if they sleep through it all, they’ll know.

If your goodbye is planned, that means you still have time. And that time, no matter how short, is sacred.

Coming up next: how to help kids say goodbye, process the grief, and find their own way to heal.

Helping Kids Say Goodbye to Their Dog

Saying goodbye to a beloved dog is hard enough, but when kids are involved, it becomes even more emotional. For many, this is their first experience with loss. They need honesty, comfort, and permission to feel everything.

Here’s how to help your child through it:

• Use Honest, Simple Language. Avoid vague phrases like “put to sleep.” Instead, say something like, “Our dog is very sick, and the vet will help them pass peacefully so they don’t hurt anymore.”
• Let Them Participate in Their Own Way. Give them the choice of whether they want to say goodbye in person or write a note. Do they want to pick a last treat?
• Give Grief an Outlet. Encourage drawing pictures, writing letters, or making a memory box. Children process emotions through action, and this can provide them with closure.
• Don’t Rush the Sadness. Tears are normal. So is laughter. Let them feel it all, at their own pace. And if they ask questions weeks later, let them.
• Show Your Own Feelings. It’s okay to cry. When you model your grief, it teaches them that love and loss go hand in hand, and it’s safe to feel both.

Helping your child say goodbye can be one of the most meaningful lessons in love they’ll ever learn.

What Comes Next: Cremation, Burial & Memorial Options

After goodbye comes silence and then questions. What happens now? Where does your dog go? What do you want to keep? What should you do with their collar, their toys, their ashes?

These aren’t easy questions. But having a plan in place, before or after euthanasia, can bring comfort and clarity in a deeply emotional moment.

Here are your main options, along with the gentle choices within each one.

Cremation

Most vets will offer private or communal cremation, and it’s the most common option. With private, your dog is cremated individually, and you receive their ashes. With communal, ashes are not returned. Ask about:

• Ashes returned in a simple urn, box, or keepsake
• Options to scatter, bury, or keep the ashes
• Paw print impressions or fur clippings as keepsakes

You can also often upgrade to special urns, lockets, or memory boxes, and some of these options can be engraved with your dog’s name or photo.

Home Burial

If local laws allow it, you may choose to bury your dog at home. This is often a comforting option for families who want a physical place to visit. Consider:

• Checking local regulations (some cities prohibit it)
• Choosing a quiet, meaningful spot in your yard or garden
• Planting a tree or flower above the site as a living tribute
• Creating a marker or plaque for remembrance

Your vet’s office can likely help you with the details and the costs involved.

Pet Cemeteries & Memorial Services

Pet cemeteries offer burial plots, headstones, and even small ceremonies. This may be a good fit if you want something formal and lasting, outside your home. Bonus: Many of these services can also help children process the goodbye in a more ceremonial, structured way.

Honoring Their Memory

Whether you cremate or bury, there are so many beautiful ways to honor your dog’s legacy:

• Frame a favorite photo or their collar
• Create a scrapbook or memory wall
• Plant a garden or light a candle on special days
• Donate to a rescue or sponsor another animal in their name
• Get a cremation tattoo, painting, or paw print cast as a tribute

There’s no “right” way to grieve, only your way. Do what feels healing, meaningful, and true to your bond. Our article on how to deal with the death of your dog can give you some insight into working through the grief process.

Keep Learning, Keep Loving

We’d Love to Hear Your Story. Have you been through this? Are you currently struggling with the decision? Share your story or ask your questions in the comments. Whether you need support, want to honor your dog’s memory, or simply want someone to say, “I understand,” we’re here.