Nutro vs. Science Diet: Which Food Fits Your Dog’s Needs Best?

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Here’s how it works.

Trying to choose the right food for your dog? Two of the most recognizable brands you’ll see are Nutro and Hill’s Science Diet. One focuses on ingredient-forward, natural recipes with simple formulations, while the other is built on decades of veterinary research and science-backed nutrition designed to support specific health needs.

We compare recall history, ingredients, and available formulas so you can decide which option is the better fit for your dog’s age, health, and lifestyle. Because the proper diet can support better digestion, healthier skin and coat, and long-term wellness, this Nutro vs. Hill’s Science Diet breakdown covers everything you need to know before choosing what goes in your dog’s bowl.

Best For Puppies	Best For Adults	Best For Seniors
Nutro Natural Choice	Hill’s Science Diet	Nutro Natural Choice
View on Amazon	View on Amazon	View on Amazon
View on Chewy	View on Chewy	View on Chewy
Read Review	Read Review	Read Review

Brand Histories

Understanding where a dog food brand comes from can help explain how it approaches nutrition today. A company’s origins often shape how its recipes are formulated and who they’re designed for.

Nutro

Nutro has been producing pet food for nearly 90 years and was among the first brands to focus on natural-style dog food and specialty recipes. The brand built its reputation around clearly named animal proteins and recipes made without artificial flavors, preservatives, or meat by-products.

Today, Nutro, a subsidiary of Mars Inc., offers a wide range of formulas designed to support dogs at different life stages, including:

• Grain-inclusive and grain-free options
• Life stage–specific recipes for puppies, adults, and seniors
• Size-based formulas for small and large breeds

The brand emphasizes ingredient simplicity and straightforward nutrition, which appeals to owners who want recognizable ingredients without highly specialized formulations.

Hill’s Science Diet

Hill’s Science Diet is produced by Hill’s Pet Nutrition, a company with roots in veterinary medicine dating back to the 1930s. The brand began when a veterinarian developed a therapeutic diet to help manage kidney disease in dogs, laying the foundation for Hill’s research-driven approach to pet nutrition.

Science Diet focuses on science-backed nutrition designed to support:

• Specific life stages
• Breed sizes
• Common health concerns

Its formulas are developed with veterinarians and nutritionists and are frequently recommended in veterinary clinics, prioritizing consistency and clinical research over ingredient trends.

Recall History

When the quality or safety of a product doesn’t meet expectations, a pet food company may issue a voluntary withdrawal, or the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) may require a recall.

Recalls can sound alarming, but they don’t automatically mean a dog food brand is unsafe. They’re best used to understand how often issues occur — and how a company responds when something goes wrong. Below are the most notable, publicly documented recalls for each brand. Note: Both brands’ recalls have been voluntary.

Nutro

Nutro has had several recalls/market withdrawals over the years. Here’s the brief history most commonly cited in public recall reporting:

• March 2007 (industry-wide): Nutro (Mars) was among many brands affected by the melamine contamination crisis tied to contaminated ingredients used across the pet food industry.
• September 2009: Voluntary withdrawal tied to potential foreign material (reports at the time described possible plastic contamination affecting select Nutro puppy products sold through specific retailers).
• December 2015: Recall/withdrawal of a limited amount of Nutro dog treats due to possible mold contamination.

Hill’s Science Diet

Hill’s (Science Diet and some Prescription Diet products) has had fewer widely cited recalls, with the major ones being:

• June 2014: Hill’s voluntarily recalled 62 bags of Science Diet dry dog food due to potential Salmonella contamination (no illnesses reported in the recall notice).
• January 31, 2019: Hill’s voluntarily recalled select canned dog foods for excessive vitamin D.
• March 20, 2019: Hill’s expanded that recall to additional products/lot codes tied to the same vitamin premix issue; the FDA posted multiple updates as the investigation developed.

What’s Really In The Bowl? Ingredients Compared

Ingredients are where Nutro and Hill’s Science Diet start to look very different — and understanding why those differences exist matters more than picking a label that sounds better.

Both brands are made in the U.S. and meet AAFCO nutritional standards, but they approach formulation from opposite directions. One emphasizes ingredient transparency and simplicity, while the other prioritizes digestibility and research-backed formulation. Neither approach is right or wrong; the better choice depends on your dog’s needs and how sensitive they are to dietary changes.

Nutro: Ingredient Transparency & Simple Formulas

Nutro emphasizes recognizable ingredients and straightforward recipes, positioning itself as an ingredient-forward alternative to more clinical diets.

Key ingredient traits include:

• Real animal protein is typically the first ingredient, most often chicken, lamb, or salmon
• Clearly named protein sources with no meat by-products
• Both grain-inclusive and grain-free formulas available
• Grain-inclusive recipes commonly use brown rice or oatmeal
• Grain-free recipes rely on legumes, such as peas and lentils
• No artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
• Healthy additives include omega fatty acids, glucosamine, and chondroitin

This approach appeals to owners who want ingredient transparency, fewer controversial ingredients, and flexibility for dogs with food sensitivities or personal dietary preferences.

Hill’s Science Diet: Nutrition Science Over Ingredient Trends

Hill’s Science Diet focuses less on ingredient marketing and more on clinical research. Their prescription diets cater to dogs with specific medical conditions and can help extend their lives.

Typical ingredient characteristics include:

• Animal-based proteins, most commonly chicken or lamb
• Primarily grain-inclusive formulas using corn, wheat, and rice
• Use of named meat by-products, which may consist of nutrient-dense organ meats
• Added vitamins, minerals, and preservatives to meet precise nutritional targets
• Very limited grain-free options and minimal use of legumes

This formulation style aligns with current veterinary nutrition guidance and is often recommended for dogs that do best on highly digestible, consistent diets rather than ingredient-driven variety.

Ingredient Comparison At A Glance

Range Of Formulas

A strong dog food brand should support dogs through every stage of life, not just adulthood. Puppies, adults, and seniors all have different nutritional requirements, and factors like breed size, activity level, and health concerns play a significant role in choosing the right formula.

The best brands do this by offering:

• Life stage–specific nutrition with balanced protein, fat, and key nutrients
• Breed-size–specific recipes that consider metabolism, vitamin/mineral needs, kibble size, and joint support
• Targeted formulas for common health concerns, such as sensitive digestion, skin and coat health, weight management, and mobility

So how do Nutro and Hill’s Science Diet compare in terms of variety and broad coverage?

Formula Availability At A Glance

Nutro offers a moderately broad selection of dry dog food formulas spread across several core product lines. Its lineup includes both grain-inclusive and grain-free options, with recipes formulated for puppies, adults, and seniors, as well as size-specific formulas for small and large breeds. Nutro focuses more on life stage and ingredient simplicity than condition-specific targeting.

Hill’s Science Diet provides a more streamlined but highly targeted lineup of dry dog food formulas. Its recipes are designed around specific life stages, breed sizes, and common health concerns, such as sensitive stomachs, skin issues, weight management, dental health, and mobility. In addition to its retail formulas, Hill’s also produces a separate Prescription Diet line, formulated under veterinary guidance for diagnosed medical conditions.

To see which brand is the better fit for your dog, let’s break down their formulas by life stage, starting with puppy food.

Puppy Formulas Comparison

The puppy stage (up to 12–18 months, depending on breed) is one of the most important phases of a dog’s life. Nutrition during this window supports bone development, muscle growth, brain function, and immune health, setting the foundation for long-term wellness.

Puppies generally need:

• Higher protein and fat to fuel growth
• DHA and omega fatty acids for brain and eye development
• Carefully balanced calcium and phosphorus, especially for large breeds

Here’s how Nutro and Hill’s Science Diet compare when it comes to puppy nutrition.

Nutro

Nutro takes a variety-first, ingredient-forward approach to puppy food, offering more flexibility across sizes and recipe styles than many competitors.

Its puppy formulas typically include:

• Multiple dry puppy recipes across its core product lines
• Grain-inclusive and grain-free options
• Size-specific formulas for small and large breed puppies
• Clearly named animal proteins, most commonly chicken or lamb
• DHA and omega fatty acids to support cognitive and visual development
• Recipes made without artificial flavors, preservatives, or by-products

This range makes Nutro appealing for puppies with food sensitivities, picky appetites, or owners who want more ingredient choice during the growth stage.

Hill’s Science Diet

Hill’s Science Diet offers a more streamlined, research-driven lineup of puppy foods focused on balanced growth and digestibility.

This brand’s puppy formulas generally feature:

• A smaller but focused selection of dry and wet puppy foods
• Primarily grain-inclusive recipes
• Chicken-based formulas, with a limited number of lamb or salmon options
• Breed-size–specific recipes for toy, small, medium, and large-breed puppies
• Added DHA from fish oil for brain and eye development
• A dedicated Sensitive Stomach & Skin puppy formula

Hill’s puppy foods are often recommended by veterinarians for owners who prefer a simple, science-backed approach without having to navigate a large number of options.

Puppy Formula Top Pick: Nutro Natural Choice Puppy Recipe Review

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

Nutro Natural Choice Puppy Chicken & Brown Rice is designed to support healthy growth with a balance of quality protein, digestible grains, and essential nutrients for developing puppies. It’s especially well-suited for owners who want a grain-inclusive puppy food made with recognizable ingredients and no by-products.

This formula uses real chicken as the first ingredient, paired with brown rice to provide steady energy and easy digestion. Added DHA and omega fatty acids help support brain, eye, skin, and coat development during this critical growth stage. The recipe is available in size-appropriate kibble options, making it a practical choice for small, medium, and large breed puppies. It also comes in a lamb and brown rice formula.

Key Features

• Real chicken as the first ingredient
• Non-GMO ingredients
• Grain-inclusive (brown rice as the primary grain)
• DHA and omega fatty acids for brain, eye, and coat health
• No corn, wheat, soy, or meat by-products
• 407 kcal/cup
• 28% protein, 16% fat, 3% fiber

Price

• Starts at $15.97 (5-lb bag)

Adult Formulas Comparison

Because dogs spend most of their lives as adults, the food you choose during this stage plays a major role in long-term health. Adult formulas should help maintain muscle, support joints and digestion, and fuel daily activity without overfeeding.

Adult dogs generally benefit from:

• Adequate protein to maintain muscle mass
• Moderate fat levels for sustained energy
• Targeted support for digestion, skin and coat health, weight control, and mobility

Here’s how Nutro and Hill’s Science Diet compare for adult dogs.

Nutro

Nutro offers a broad adult lineup built around ingredient transparency and life-stage nutrition rather than condition-specific targeting.

Adult Nutro formulas typically include:

• Multiple adult recipes across its core product lines
• Grain-inclusive and grain-free options
• Size-specific formulas for small and large breeds
• Clearly named animal proteins, most commonly chicken, lamb, or salmon
• Recipes made without artificial flavors, preservatives, or meat by-products
• Added omega fatty acids and essential nutrients for overall health

This variety makes Nutro a good fit for healthy adult dogs, picky eaters, or owners who want flexibility in ingredients and protein choices.

Hill’s Science Diet

Hill’s Science Diet tends to shine in the adult category thanks to its wide range of non-prescription, condition-focused formulas.

Adult formulas commonly feature:

• Size-specific recipes for small, medium, and large breeds
• Primarily grain-inclusive diets designed for digestibility
• Animal proteins such as chicken or lamb
• Targeted options for common adult needs, including:
  • Sensitive stomach & skin
  • Weight management
  • Joint and mobility support
  • Dental health
• Formulas developed alongside veterinarians and nutritionists

This approach makes Hill’s especially appealing for adult dogs that need extra nutritional support without moving to a prescription diet.

Adult Formula Top Pick: Hill’s Science Diet Hill’s Science Diet Adult Sensitive Stomach & Skin

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

Hill’s Science Diet Adult Sensitive Stomach & Skin is one of the brand’s most popular adult formulas — and for good reason. It’s designed for dogs that struggle with digestive upset, food sensitivities, or chronic skin and coat issues, without requiring a veterinary prescription.

This recipe uses highly digestible ingredients to support gut health while delivering targeted nutrients for skin and coat support. The chicken-based formula is widely available, and a salmon option offers an alternative protein for dogs that don’t tolerate chicken well. Hill’s also offers size-specific versions, making it easier to match the food to your dog’s needs.

This formula is a strong choice for adult dogs that need daily digestive support and skin care, especially when frequent food changes haven’t worked.

Key Features

• Highly digestible ingredients for sensitive stomachs
• Prebiotic fiber to support gut microbiome health
• Omega-6 fatty acids and vitamin E for skin & coat
• Grain-inclusive
• Veterinarian-recommended for digestive and skin support
• 382 kcal per cup
• 20% protein, 13% fat, 4% fiber

Price

• $57.99 (15.5-lb bag)

Senior Formulas Comparison

As dogs age, their nutritional needs shift. Senior formulas are designed to support joint health, easier digestion, and healthy weight maintenance, while still providing enough protein to preserve lean muscle.

Senior dogs typically benefit from:

• Moderate protein to maintain muscle without overloading aging systems
• Controlled calories and fat to help prevent weight gain
• Joint-support nutrients like glucosamine and chondroitin
• Antioxidants and omega fatty acids for immune and skin support

Here’s how Nutro and Hill’s Science Diet compare for senior nutrition.

Nutro

Nutro offers a broader senior-specific lineup with a strong emphasis on joint support and ingredient simplicity.

Senior Nutro formulas commonly include:

• Multiple senior recipes across core product lines
• Grain-inclusive and grain-free options
• Size-specific formulas for small and large senior dogs
• Clearly named animal proteins with no meat by-products
• Added glucosamine and chondroitin, particularly in large-breed recipes
• Omega fatty acids and essential vitamins for aging skin and immune systems

This makes Nutro a good fit for seniors with mobility concerns, owners looking for joint-support ingredients, or dogs that do best on simpler, ingredient-forward diets.

Hill’s Science Diet

Science Diet takes a more targeted but narrower approach to senior nutrition, focusing on digestibility and vitality rather than variety.

Hill’s senior formulas generally feature:

• Senior dry food options are primarily labeled Adult 7+ or Senior Vitality 7+
• Size-specific recipes, including Small & Mini senior formulas
• Primarily grain-inclusive diets
• Chicken-based protein sources are used in most recipes
• Emphasis on digestion, energy levels, and cognitive engagement

While Hill’s includes nutrients that support skin, coat, and overall vitality, the brand does not consistently list clear glucosamine or chondroitin levels across its senior lineup, making direct joint-support comparisons more difficult.

Senior Formula Top Pick: Nutro Natural Choice Senior Dog Food Review

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

Nutro Natural Choice Senior Dog Food is a solid option for aging dogs that need joint support and easy-to-digest nutrition without overly complex ingredients. It’s especially well-suited for seniors who are slowing down but still benefit from quality protein and targeted mobility support.

This formula uses real chicken as the first ingredient and includes added glucosamine and chondroitin to help support joint health — a key advantage for older dogs, particularly larger breeds. Nutro keeps the ingredient list straightforward, avoiding meat by-products, corn, wheat, and soy, which many owners prefer for long-term feeding.

Key Features

• Real chicken as the first ingredient
• Added glucosamine and chondroitin for joint support
• Grain-inclusive recipe with gentle, digestible ingredients
• Omega fatty acids to support skin and coat health
• No corn, wheat, soy, or meat by-products
• 343 kcal/cup
• 26% protein, 12% fat, 4% fiber

Price

• $37.98 (13-lb bag)

Wet Food Comparison

Wet dog food can be a helpful addition to your dog’s diet, whether it’s served as a full meal or mixed with kibble for added moisture and flavor. It’s often especially useful for picky eaters, senior dogs, and dogs that need extra hydration.

When comparing canned food options, variety, ingredient style, and life-stage coverage matter just as much as nutrition.

Nutro

Nutro offers a wider selection of wet dog food, with an emphasis on simple recipes and ingredient transparency.

Nutro’s wet food lineup typically includes:

• Multiple canned recipes across puppy, adult, and senior life stages
• Grain-free wet foods across most of its canned offerings
• Clearly named animal proteins like chicken, beef, lamb, or turkey
• No artificial flavors, preservatives, or meat by-products
• Options that work well as a complete meal or kibble topper

This range makes Nutro a strong option for dogs with changing appetites, food sensitivities, or owners who prefer grain-free canned food.

Hill’s Science Diet

Hill’s Science Diet takes a more focused approach to wet food, prioritizing consistency and alignment with its dry formulas.

Its wet food options generally feature:

• Canned recipes for puppies, adults, and seniors
• Primarily grain-inclusive formulas
• Protein sources such as chicken, turkey, or beef
• Select options designed for sensitive stomachs, weight management, or aging dogs
• Nutrient profiles intended to pair easily with Science Diet dry food

Hill’s wet foods are often chosen by owners who want predictable nutrition and minimal changes when combining wet and dry feeding.

Wet Formula Top Pick: Nutro Hearty Stew Review

View on Amazon | View on Chewy

Nutro Hearty Stew is a popular choice for dogs that enjoy a more textured, homestyle meal. It works well as a standalone food or a flavorful topper, especially for picky eaters, seniors, or dogs that benefit from extra moisture in their diet.

This recipe features real chicken as the primary protein and skips meat by-products, corn, wheat, and soy. It’s also available in beef, lamb, and turkey. Like most of Nutro’s canned foods, it’s grain-free, which appeals to owners looking for simpler ingredient lists or avoiding grains in wet food.

The stew-style texture provides visible pieces of meat and vegetables, making it more appealing to dogs who turn their noses up at pâté-style cans.

Key Features

• Real chicken as the main ingredient
• Grain-free recipe
• No meat by-products, corn, wheat, or soy
• Stew-style texture with visible ingredients
• Suitable as a complete meal or kibble topper
• 279 kcal/can
• 9% protein, 3% fat, 1% fiber

Price

• $46.68 (12.5-oz can (Pack of 12))

Final Verdict: Nutro vs. Hill’s Science Diet

Nutro and Hill’s Science Diet are both long-standing, reputable dog food brands, but they’re built for different types of dogs — and different types of dog owners.

Hill’s Science Diet leans heavily into research-driven, veterinarian-formulated nutrition, making it a strong option for adult and senior dogs that need targeted support for digestion, skin issues, weight control, or mobility. Its formulas favor consistency and clinical balance over ingredient variety, which is why it’s commonly recommended in veterinary settings.

Nutro, on the other hand, focuses on ingredient clarity and flexibility. With broader options for puppies, seniors, and wet food — along with grain-free and grain-inclusive recipes made without by-products — Nutro gives owners more control over ingredient style while still meeting everyday nutritional needs.

If your dog has ongoing sensitivities, age-related concerns, or does best on a predictable, vet-backed formula, Hill’s Science Diet is often the safer long-term choice. For healthy dogs, picky eaters, or owners who prioritize recognizable ingredients and variety, Nutro offers more room to tailor the bowl.

The Bottom Line

Hill’s Science Diet →
Best for adult and senior dogs that need targeted nutritional support for digestion, skin and coat health, weight management, or mobility. A solid choice for owners who prefer research-backed, grain-inclusive formulas developed alongside veterinarians.

Nutro →
Best for puppies, seniors, wet food variety, and owners who want ingredient-forward recipes without meat by-products. Offers more flexibility with grain-free options and simpler ingredient lists for healthy dogs.

Beyond Kibble & Cans

Dog food has expanded well beyond traditional kibble and canned options. Some owners now choose fresh or air-dried foods to add variety or moisture, or to better match their dog’s preferences. These alternatives can work well for some dogs, but they’re usually more expensive and not necessary for every diet.

Fresh brands like The Farmer’s Dog and Ollie use lightly cooked, minimally processed ingredients, while air-dried options from Spot & Tango and Badlands Ranch offer higher meat content with shelf-stable convenience. We’ve reviewed and tested these options to help you decide if one might be right for your dog.

Have you used Nutro or Hill’s Science Diet for your dog? We’d love to hear about your experience in the comments, including what your dog liked (or didn’t) and which brands you’d suggest to other owners.